Skip to main content
. 2015 Apr 9;8:60. doi: 10.1186/s13068-015-0239-6

Table 5.

Comparative average resistances of superior isolates to 6, 10, and 15 g/L acetic acid in ODM with 50 g/L sugar a,b

Adaptation stress Isolate Average μ o (h −1 ) c Average ratio μ i o c
Glucose Xylose Glucose Xylose
AFEX CSH 33 Colony 5 0.23 AB 0.23 A 0.86 AB 0.90 B
AFEX CSH > E 27 2A.1.53R-E20-C1 0.28 A 0.26 A 0.72 AB 0.80 B
AFEX CSH > E 28 2A.1.53R-E30-C3 0.26 AB 0.24 A 0.75 AB 0.68 B
AFEX CSH > E (UV) 30 2A.1.30R2-E40-C5 0.24 AB 0.21 A 0.93 AB 1.10 A
AFEX CSH > E > PSGHL 13 2A.1.53R S100E40-1 0.26 AB 0.25 A 0.84 AB 0.79 B
AFEX CSH > E > PSGHL 16 2A.1.53R-1 0.25 AB 0.24 A 0.88 AB 0.75 B
AFEX CSH > PSGHL 11 Colony 5-GP6 0.22 B 0.25 A 1.02 A 0.84 B
PSGHL 3 Y-7124 S90E40-1 0.25 AB 0.22 A 0.66 B 0.83 B
PSGHL 15 Y-7124-10 0.25 AB 0.24 A 0.97 A 0.85 B
PSGHL 14 Y-7124-6 0.23 AB 0.23 A 0.84 AB 0.81 B
Wild 1 Y-7124 0.24 AB 0.25 A 0.96 AB 0.87 B
Significance P = 0.039 P = 0.223 P < 0.01 P < 0.001
Acetic acid (g/L) Average ratio μ i o d
Glucose Xylose
6 0.98 A 0.98 A
10 0.80 B 0.89 B
15 0.79 B 0.64 C
Significance P < 0.001 P < 0.001

aAbbreviations are the following: μo = initial specific growth rate in the absence of acetic acid; μi = the specific growth rate in the presence of the inhibitory acetic acid.

bWithin columns, values with no letters in common are significantly different at P < 0.05 (Student-Newman-Keuls pairwise comparison method).

cAverage across acetic acid concentrations for a particular isolate.

dAverage across isolates for a particular acetic acid concentration.