Table 1.
Summary of key findings and future directions for the application of sleep hygiene to the general population
Sleep hygiene recommendation | Summary of Findings | Directions for future research |
---|---|---|
Avoid caffeine | • Caffeine administration close to bedtime disrupts sleep • Effects of caffeine on sleep show a dose-response relationship • The impact of morning and afternoon caffeine use is less clear • Harmful effects of caffeine on sleep may be limited to caffeine-sensitive individuals • Tolerance to caffeine's effects on sleep develops within days |
• Morning and afternoon caffeine use • Intermittent caffeine use and the importance of day-to-day variation • Tolerance and habituation • Identification and targeting of caffeine-sensitive individuals |
Avoid nicotine | • Acute and chronic nicotine administration/smoking disrupts sleep • Arousals increase temporarily during acute nicotine withdrawal • Few/limited studies suggest sleep problems associated with smoking can be resolved after cessation and withdrawal |
• Longitidunal assessments of change in sleep from pre- to post-cessation • Threshold for occasional and/or light use to impact sleep • Extent to which passive smoking disrupts sleep |
Avoid alcohol | • Acute alcohol administration before bed decreases SOL but increases arousal during second half of night • The effects of alcohol on sleep are dose-dependent • Tolerance to alcohol's effects on sleep occurs within days • Sleep problems increase during acute withdrawal of dependent users • Despite modest improvement, long-term sleep problems persist in abstinent former users |
• Longitudinal assessments of change in sleep during use and abstinence for dependent users • Direct tests of alcohol avoidance effects on sleep in nondependent useres • The impact of afternoon and evening use on sleep • The effect of non-dependent use patterns (e.g., light/occasional, habitual weekend use) • Combined effects of alcohol with nicotine and caffeine on sleep |
Exercise regularly | • Regular and/or acute bouts of exercise produce modest improvements in sleep for individuals with and without sleep complaints (though impact of exercise training on PSG-assessed sleep is less consistent) • Current evidence does not support the claim that late-night exercise disrupts sleep |
• Extent to which different types, duration, and intensity level of exercise can be specified for optimal sleep improvement • Moderating effects of age, gender, and fitness level on the impact of exercise on sleep |
Manage stress | • Psychosocial stress is associated with increased pre-sleep arousal and impaired sleep • Various stress management strategies have been shown to reduce pre-sleep arousal and improve sleep (most often self-reported sleep) • Individual differences influence perception of stress and coping style |
• Identify patterns in individual differences to predict those whose sleep is most affected by stress • Examine the isolated benefit of stress management beyond reduction in physiological arousal • Develop process by which individuals can evaluate their own stressors and identify the most appropriate stress management technique for their needs |
Reduce bedroom noise | • Nighttime noise increases arousals • Habituation to noises occurs, but EEG arousals persist • Specific noise reduction strategies have been shown to improve sleep in some environments (most often in ICU patients) |
• Further test noise-attenuating strategies in home environments using objective sleep assessments • Identify individual-level factors (e.g., age) that influence preference and efficacy of specific strategies |
Sleep timing regularity | • Clinical sleep treatments encourage regularity only in wake time, which is counter to some sleep hygiene recommendations to adopt regular bed- and wake-times • Irregular sleep schedules have been associated with poor sleep, but assigning regular sleep schedules to nonclinical adults has shown limited effects on sleep improvement |
• Relative importance of bed- vs. wake-time regularity in nonclinical samples • Influence of moderating factors (e.g., chronotype, age) • Threshold for schedule regularity required to promote good sleep |
Avoid daytime naps | • Most research suggests that daytime naps do not have a substantial impact on subjective or objective nocturnal sleep, despite sleep hygiene recommendations to avoid naps • Nap duration and timing seem to have limited effects on the relationship between napping and nocturnal sleep |
• Impact of nap elimination on nocturnal sleep in habitual nappers with poor sleep • Examination of naps in the home environment rather than laboratory • Moderating effect of age |
Note. EEG=electroencephalography; ICU=Intensive Care Unit; PSG=polysomnography; SOL=sleep onset latency.