Skip to main content
. 2015 Apr 16;53(5):1639–1647. doi: 10.1128/JCM.03480-14

TABLE 3.

Combined results after resolution of discrepancies

Target and specimen type No. of specimens with BD Max EBP result with reference to culture/EIA or alternate PCRa
Total no. of specimensc PPA (95% confidence interval) P value for PPAd NPA (95% confidence interval) P value for NPAd
True positive False negative False positive True negative
Campylobacter
    Total 195 5 31 3,170 3,401 97.5 (94.3–99.2) 99.0 (98.6–99.3)
    Prospective 66 1 29 2,797 2,893 98.5 (91.3–99.7) 0.867 99.0 (98.5–99.3) 0.525
    Retrospectiveb 129 4 2 373 508 97.0 (92.5–98.8) 99.5 (98.1–99.9)
Salmonella
    Total 219 6 8 3,307 3,540 97.3 (94.3–99.0) 99.8 (94.5–99.9)
    Prospective 53 5 7 2,857 2,922 91.4 (81.0–97.1) 0.005 99.8 (99.5–99.9) 1.000
    Retrospective 166 1 1 450 618 99.4 (96.7–99.9) 99.8 (98.8–100)
Shigella
    Total 124 1 1 3,340 3,466 99.2 (95.6–99.9) 100 (99.8–100)
    Prospective 33 0 1 2,889 2,923 100 (89.3–100) 1.000 100 (99.8–100) 1.000
    Retrospective 91 1 0 451 543 98.9 (94.1–99.8) 100 (99.2–100)
Shiga toxins
    Total 85 0 8 2,437 2,530 100 (95.7–100) 99.7 (99.4–99.9)
    Prospective 19 0 8 2,347 2,374 100 (82.2–100) 1.000 99.7(99.3–99.9) 1.000
    Retrospective 66 0 0 90 156 100 (94.5–100) 100 (95.9–100)
a

For Campylobacter spp., Salmonella spp., and Shigella spp., a positive result by either culture or alternate PCR was considered a true-positive result. For the resolution of discrepant results for Shiga toxins, results of alternate PCR were considered true-positive results.

b

Results for all retrospective samples were confirmed by alternate PCR and bidirectional sequencing prior to testing with the BD Max EBP assay. Discrepancies were not further resolved.

c

The number of prospective specimens varies by target due to differences in compliance with the study protocol and unresolved results.

d

P value for testing of the significance of the difference between prospective and retrospective data sets.