Extended Data Table 1. Comparison of surrogate variable analyses with direct white cell counts in association models.
The table shows the I values from regression models in the MRCA panel that predict lnIgE at each locus a) before adjusting cell counts; b) after adjusting cell counts using Houseman surrogate variables; c) after adjusting for cell subsets counted in our data. pMethyl measures strength of association to IgE. CD8, CD4 and NK are Tcell subsets, GRAN= granulocytes, EOS=eosinophils, NEU=neutrophil, LYM=lymphocytes, MON=monocytes, BAS=basophils. All models are adjusted for sex, age, methylation, parent/child status, sex*age interaction, and age*parent interaction.
a) Before adjusting cell counts |
b) Adjusting for Houseman cell proportions |
c) Adjusting for white cell counts |
|||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Chr. | Position | Symbol | probe | pMethy | pMethy | pCD8T | pCD4T | pNK | pBCELL | pMON | pGRAN | pMethy | pEOS | pNEU | pLYM | pMON | pBAS |
1 | 9521654 | SLC25A33 | cg18783781 | 4.96E-14 | 5.58E-13 | 0.3625663 | 0.6489145 | 0.0830001 | 0.0735391 | 0.7715233 | 0.2564499 | 6.14 E-06 | 0.00065 | 0.866661 | 0.678896 | 0.561016 | 0.551752 |
16 | 54100210 | LPCAT2 | cg01998785 | 1.24E-13 | 3.81E-13 | 0.1560292 | 0.3633042 | 0.034881 | 0.0300831 | 0.7239839 | 0.1881862 | 2.36E-06 | 0.0003 | 0.294806 | 0.300248 | 0.445243 | 0.785135 |
14 | 49849865 | L2HGDH | cg15996947 | 7.39E-13 | 3.81E-11 | 0.3709841 | 0.6823007 | 0.125117 | 0.1583239 | 0.9387673 | 0.3768824 | 3.21E-05 | 0.000295 | 0.38062 | 0.519495 | 0.662394 | 0.890493 |
10 | 44815441 | ZNF22 | cg01614759 | 4.42E-12 | 9.09E-11 | 0.3526504 | 0.6420391 | 0.1382946 | 0.0810812 | 0.654088 | 0.3845248 | 7.61E-05 | 0.000216 | 0.305013 | 0.42021 | 0.601202 | 0.937252 |
3 | 3127530 | IL5RA | cg10159529 | 5.06E-12 | 1.70E-10 | 0.8786628 | 0.9388517 | 0.2941882 | 0.2701973 | 0.9752202 | 0.5129874 | 0.000104 | 6.81E-05 | 0.877227 | 0.802458 | 0.551635 | 0.756105 |
1 | 172153108 | SERPINC1 | cg01770400 | 6.59E-12 | 1.54E-11 | 0.1182883 | 0.3063038 | 0.0323251 | 0.0368702 | 0.574556 | 0.1896 | 6.36E-06 | 0.000109 | 0.236406 | 0.186757 | 0.667289 | 0.90807 |
21 | 42659768 | TFF1 | cg02643667 | 7.87E-12 | 6.81E-11 | 0.234861 | 0.4646176 | 0.0330799 | 0.0706689 | 0.797703 | 0.1753888 | 9.07E-06 | 7.18E-06 | 0.384611 | 0.725574 | 0.672431 | 0.976409 |
5 | 132036424 | IL4 | cg26787239 | 1.59E-11 | 2.13E-10 | 0.5058003 | 0.9922092 | 0.1723318 | 0.1996409 | 0.7364825 | 0.6544331 | 1.25E-05 | 1.66E-05 | 0.269226 | 0.259295 | 0.614387 | 0.77939 |
2 | 110014086 | LIMS3 | cg18879041 | 4.06E-11 | 2.57E-09 | 0.3708111 | 0.7030526 | 0.1613161 | 0.2166898 | 0.9745824 | 0.474026 | 0.000865 | 0.000256 | 0.280498 | 0.382954 | 0.500203 | 0.963467 |
13 | 47774920 | RB1 | cg13221796 | 5.66E-10 | 9.26E-11 | 0.1278218 | 0.3641314 | 0.0353766 | 0.0458363 | 0.7786051 | 0.2987393 | 2.84E-06 | 1.83E-05 | 0.029037 | 0.081617 | 0.516731 | 0.982861 |
19 | 60432000 | TMEM86B | cg26457013 | 1.02E-09 | 4.08E-09 | 0.3305229 | 0.5920938 | 0.036091 | 0.0792481 | 0.9078355 | 0.2711535 | 0.000691 | 1.35E-05 | 0.363948 | 0.317448 | 0.558421 | 0.740734 |
9 | 100745613 | COL15A1 | cg20503329 | 1.19E-09 | 3.14E-08 | 0.4772819 | 0.7388277 | 0.1359031 | 0.1343368 | 0.9433195 | 0.4284566 | 0.001341 | 1.17E-05 | 0.443838 | 0.49736 | 0.401174 | 0.959364 |
1 | 31166502 | SDC3 | cg07689731 | 2.33E-09 | 4.79E-09 | 0.5074834 | 0.7985815 | 0.0774502 | 0.0726484 | 0.7924958 | 0.4108301 | 0.002906 | 1.48E-05 | 0.415182 | 0.483806 | 0.437372 | 0.932638 |
21 | 45317773 | ADARB1 | cg09676390 | 1.21E-08 | 1.32E-07 | 0.43369 | 0.6702876 | 0.0791369 | 0.1103603 | 0.9234331 | 0.3292778 | 0.000472 | 3.48E-07 | 0.432091 | 0.530921 | 0.462608 | 0.820656 |
9 | 134926722 | CEL | cg03693099 | 1.84E-08 | 1.01E-07 | 0.2926779 | 0.512945 | 0.0818301 | 0.1071869 | 0.9754856 | 0.3848947 | 0.000383 | 9.27E-06 | 0.099207 | 0.18224 | 0.575481 | 0.93957 |
19 | 12859426 | KLF1 | cg26136776 | 3.34E-08 | 5.42E-07 | 0.2328607 | 0.4764967 | 0.0498737 | 0.087521 | 0.7661611 | 0.2312155 | 0.008494 | 4.25E-06 | 0.308908 | 0.378613 | 0.526765 | 0.764392 |
X | 48529968 | GATA1 | cg00536175 | 7.85E-08 | 5.70E-07 | 0.6056632 | 0.9159691 | 0.163687 | 0.1102612 | 0.8082841 | 0.5675393 | 0.002444 | 1.31E-06 | 0.230592 | 0.333849 | 0.423511 | 0.745501 |
12 | 10222881 | TMEM52B | cg25494227 | 1.29E-07 | 2.79E-07 | 0.4810187 | 0.6746518 | 0.0457622 | 0.0735827 | 0.9017706 | 0.3386288 | 8.31E-05 | 2.05E-08 | 0.349366 | 0.362883 | 0.456694 | 0.75634 |
9 | 33229641 | SPINK4 | cg00079056 | 1.54E-07 | 1.23E-06 | 0.3893041 | 0.6595419 | 0.067607 | 0.090288 | 0.950103 | 0.3262354 | 0.015058 | 9.70E-07 | 0.327361 | 0.481372 | 0.49343 | 0.779557 |
12 | 15017287 | PDE6H | cg09447105 | 2.16E-07 | 1.80E-06 | 0.6038815 | 0.9752817 | 0.1325361 | 0.2619219 | 0.6725442 | 0.6818338 | 0.002327 | 6.73E-07 | 0.185319 | 0.308805 | 0.650588 | 0.72691 |
16 | 4778723 | FLJ25410 | cg05215575 | 3.11E-07 | 7.40E-08 | 0.6354446 | 0.6693211 | 0.0382164 | 0.0635217 | 0.8705757 | 0.2084314 | 0.011151 | 9.08E-08 | 0.699883 | 0.891282 | 0.341595 | 0.856081 |
7 | 142369547 | KEL | cg17784922 | 4.24E-07 | 9.07E-07 | 0.6926023 | 0.9854571 | 0.0699431 | 0.1577229 | 0.8028496 | 0.5052827 | 0.001391 | 3.21E-08 | 0.505128 | 0.698535 | 0.367309 | 0.99912 |
7 | 29199993 | CHN2 | cg21472642 | 6.51E-07 | 7.39E-07 | 0.5225896 | 0.8312874 | 0.0708089 | 0.0764603 | 0.9022296 | 0.4725488 | 8.45E-06 | 3.38E-09 | 0.104506 | 0.231601 | 0.595919 | 0.815002 |
2 | 191009029 | FLJ20160 | cg15998761 | 9.33E-07 | 9.09E-06 | 0.4236314 | 0.824669 | 0.1393183 | 0.1145142 | 0.8527446 | 0.4643437 | 0.043732 | 5.71E-07 | 0.331558 | 0.449501 | 0.418024 | 0.785659 |
6 | 25862169 | SLC17A4 | cg21627181 | 1.14E-06 | 1.42E-06 | 0.7663137 | 0.9149808 | 0.0591244 | 0.1414494 | 0.9511792 | 0.3972344 | 0.025202 | 5.30E-08 | 0.609342 | 0.865393 | 0.467443 | 0.746032 |
14 | 49849874 | L2HGDH | cg20189937 | 1.32E-06 | 1.16E-05 | 0.503935 | 0.9204654 | 0.0921306 | 0.1950088 | 0.8817908 | 0.5174749 | 0.007269 | 1.26E-07 | 0.297519 | 0.525586 | 0.480584 | 0.958405 |
17 | 39822093 | ITGA2B | cg17749520 | 1.37E-06 | 9.24E-06 | 0.3677214 | 0.6752543 | 0.046072 | 0.1157269 | 0.8717913 | 0.3274826 | 0.009625 | 3.11E-07 | 0.286277 | 0.406727 | 0.666483 | 0.903995 |
17 | 39701014 | SLC4A1 | cg03580247 | 1.51E-06 | 1.76E-05 | 0.4966594 | 0.7030166 | 0.1566437 | 0.1201467 | 0.7706213 | 0.4809553 | 9.19E-05 | 7.97E-09 | 0.262889 | 0.282218 | 0.522557 | 0.944193 |
20 | 41789039 | FAM112A | cg11398517 | 2.42E-06 | 2.11E-05 | 0.431888 | 0.7316467 | 0.0506171 | 0.209415 | 0.8337169 | 0.4256838 | 0.006763 | 1.86E-07 | 0.220078 | 0.444385 | 0.592602 | 0.918166 |
11 | 56904791 | PRG3 | cg24459209 | 3.33E-06 | 1.29E-05 | 0.5460024 | 0.9366639 | 0.0692143 | 0.1545826 | 0.8947187 | 0.4338765 | 0.094895 | 2.69E-07 | 0.444762 | 0.62114 | 0.500854 | 0.993962 |
12 | 7792928 | CLEC4C | cg22194129 | 5.46E-06 | 0.0001208 | 0.4977092 | 0.8378959 | 0.0710935 | 0.6019842 | 0.8886589 | 0.4447889 | 0.023532 | 2.38E-08 | 0.408481 | 0.759002 | 0.521453 | 0.818552 |
14 | 95011802 | C14orf49 | cg16522484 | 8.04E-06 | 0.0001668 | 0.4308412 | 0.7282314 | 0.1486239 | 0.1112817 | 0.9482318 | 0.4206034 | 0.034072 | 1.01E-07 | 0.285777 | 0.449644 | 0.49125 | 0.837548 |
X | 48529554 | GATA1 | cg22543648 | 9.51E-06 | 7.12E-05 | 0.682124 | 0.9511741 | 0.1312401 | 0.1917101 | 0.6997158 | 0.4748147 | 0.02664 | 2.00E-08 | 0.585973 | 0.689124 | 0.425854 | 0.888172 |
2 | 11727816 | NTSR2 | cg25657834 | 1.02E-05 | 2.04E-05 | 0.9354409 | 0.6331433 | 0.1373482 | 0.3261244 | 0.4920064 | 0.8015518 | 5.67E-05 | 4.84E-10 | 0.191813 | 0.526463 | 0.689339 | 0.954103 |
19 | 48912054 | IRGC | cg26251865 | 1.76E-05 | 9.19E-06 | 0.714389 | 0.9562959 | 0.0555475 | 0.1095196 | 0.6922884 | 0.4367507 | 0.011533 | 1.35E-08 | 0.495745 | 0.567965 | 0.468957 | 0.977824 |
19 | 44919789 | CLC | cg18254848 | 1.77E-05 | 2.33E-05 | 0.7122613 | 0.874791 | 0.0834931 | 0.1954486 | 0.6341788 | 0.5277066 | 0.161753 | 4.77E-08 | 0.462599 | 0.67872 | 0.424877 | 0.937408 |
6 | 10635801 | GCNT2 | cg26385286 | 1.78E-05 | 3.88E-05 | 0.5747779 | 0.9758809 | 0.0654066 | 0.2046998 | 0.6574459 | 0.5308099 | 0.070861 | 4.31E-08 | 0.339931 | 0.593173 | 0.451377 | 0.902264 |
3 | 150064527 | CPA3 | cg13424229 | 1.89E-05 | 2.29E-06 | 0.4329161 | 0.6962458 | 0.1048729 | 0.0674688 | 0.7084296 | 0.6214492 | 0.001236 | 4.96E-07 | 0.054043 | 0.094343 | 0.451245 | 0.955257 |