Table 2.
# | Potential Reason | Brief Description | Example Comments |
---|---|---|---|
Misplaced or Redundant Information in Free-Text | |||
1 | Misplaced – use Smoking status field | Smoking status field includes 10 values, including “Heavy Tobacco Smoker” and “Passive Smoker” | • hx of heavy tobacco use • exposed to second hand smoke |
2 | Misplaced – use Packs/day field | Could be entered using Packs/day field | • 50 years 2ppd = 100+ pack-years • 30yr × 0.5 ppd |
3 | Misplaced – use Years field | Could be entered using Years field | • 50 years 2ppd = 100+ pack-years • 30yr × 0.5 ppd |
4 | Misplaced – use Type field | Could be entered using options for Types (e.g., cigarettes, pipe, or cigars) | • Occasional cigar • Pipe |
5 | Misplaced – use Start or Quit date field | Could be entered using Start or Quit date fields | • quit 4/3/2011 • Quit just recently. (8/16/13) |
6 | Redundant Text | Same/synonymous information in comment also entered into structured fields | • Former smoker • nonsmoker |
Missing Values in Available Structured Fields | |||
7 | Missing value for Type field | Comment includes type that is not among available values for Type field | • Switched to an inhaler • electronic cigarette |
Limited Capabilities of Available Structured Fields | |||
8 | Limited ability to describe amount | Comment includes amount that cannot be described using available fields (Packs/day and Pack years fields) | • 1–2 cigars a day • 2 cans weekly • a few a day |
9 | Limited ability to describe frequency | Comment includes frequency that cannot be described using available fields (Packs/day) | • Smoked cigars sporadically • occasional pipe • a few a day |
10 | Limited ability to describe start or quit date | Comment includes a date that cannot be described using Start date or Quit date fields that require mm/dd/yy | • Quit April 2010 • Quit one year ago • Quit 1971 |
11 | Limited ability to describe start or quit age | Comment includes an age related to starting or quitting | • smoked until age 16 • from age 18–26 |
12 | Limited ability to describe duration or timepoint | Comment includes tobacco use or quit duration or timepoint | • Many years • Quit for 10 yr |
13 | Limited ability to describe situation | Comment includes information about situation or context of tobacco use | • Social • occasional in college |
14 | Limited ability to describe cessation attempts | Comment includes information about quit attempts, interventions, etc. | • Would like to quit • Working on quitting |
15 | Limited ability to describe passive smoke exposure | Comment includes information about passive smoke exposure that cannot be described in available fields | • Parents smoke in the home • No second hand smoke |
16 | Limited ability to specify multiple values | Comment includes additional status, age/date, etc. | • Quit 04/12/2008, restarted in 07/2008, quit 2/2010 |
Other | |||
17 | Multiple statements | Comment includes multiple pieces of information | • 1–2 cigarettes/day. Quit on /1/13. |
18 | Other | Any other reason for use | • Smokes marijuana daily |