Table 5.
Study | Intervention target | Sensors | Tailoring | App-based | EMI frequency | EMI duration | Immediate Post-intervention effects | Long-term effects |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Obermayer et al., 2004 | Smoking cessation | x | Variant; At least 2 per day; Combined with website | 6 weeks | xa | |||
Rodgers et al., 2005 | Smoking cessation | x | 5 per day for 6 weeks; 3 per week thereafter | 6 months | x | x | ||
Franklin et al., 2006 | Type 1 diabetes management | x | 1 daily and 1 weekly message | 12 months | x | |||
Kim and Jeong, 2007 | Type 2 diabetes management | x | Weekly | 6 months | x | |||
Joo and Kim, 2007 | Weight management behavior | Weekly | 12 weeks | x | ||||
Hurling et al., 2007 | Physical activity | x | x | Tailored; Combined with website and email | 4 months | x | ||
Weitzel et al., 2007 | Negative consequences of drinking | x | Daily surveys and messages | 2 weeks | x | |||
Yoon and Kim, 2008 | Type 2 diabetes management | x | Weekly | 12 months | x | |||
Brendryen et al., 2008 | Smoking cessation | Between 1 and 3 messages every 2 weeks; Combined with website, interview and email | 12 months | x | x | |||
Atienza et al., 2008 | Dietary intake | x | 2 per day | 8 weeks | x | |||
King et al., 2008 | Physical activity | x | 2 daily assessments; 1 daily & weekly tailored | 8 weeks | x | |||
Patrick et al., 2009 | Weight loss | x | Variant; Typically 1–5 per day | 4 months | x | |||
Rizvi et al., 2011 | Borderline personality disorder and substance use disorder | x | On average 15 times total | 10–14 days | x | |||
Burns et al., 2011 | Major depressive disorder | x | x | Tailored | 8 weeks | xa | ||
Pop-Eleches et al., 2011 | Antiretroviral therapy adherence | Weekly | 48 weeks | x | ||||
Granholm et al., 2012 | Schizophrenia-related medication adherence, socialization and hallucinations | 12 per day; Combined with initial training | 12 weeks | x | ||||
Villani et al., 2012 | Stress | x | 8 videos | 4 weeks | x | |||
Kauer et al., 2012 | Emotional self-awareness and depressive symptoms | x | Approximately 2 per day (self-initiated) | 2–4 weeks | x | |||
Watts et al., 2013 | Depression | x | 6 sessions; Combined with weekly assignments and email | n/a | x | x | ||
Robinson et al., 2013 | Eating behaviors and weight management | x | x | 2.7 episodes on average (user-initiated) | 27.5 days on average | xb | ||
Carta et al., 2013 | Parenting strategies and child engagement | 2 per day; Combined with training home visits and weekly phone calls | Not specified | x | x | |||
King et al., 2013 | Motivation and physical activity | x | x | x | Live wallpaper and 1 end of day intervention; Combined with user-initiated features, texts and weekly alerts if goals weren't met | 8 weeks | x | |
Wayne and Ritvo, 2014 | Self-management of type 2 diabetes | x | x | User-initiated; Combined with phone calls and in person meetings | 6 months | x | ||
Enock et al., 2014 | Social anxiety | x | 3 per day | 4 weeks | x | |||
Bless et al., 2014 | Auditory attention | x | x | 2 per day | 21 days | x | ||
Ben-Zeev et al., 2014 | Schizophrenia | x | 5.2 per day on average | 1 month | x | |||
Bond et al., 2014 | Sedentary time reduction | x | x | x | Dependent on activity levels; Combined with education session | 3 weeks | x | |
Dulin et al., 2014 | Treatment of alcohol use disorders | x | x | x | Variant; Location-based | 6 weeks | x | |
Lane et al., 2014 | Sleep, physical activity, social interaction | x | x | x | Constantly accessible summary data | 19 days | xc | |
Maddison et al., 2014 | Self-efficacy and exercise | Variant; First 12-weeks more intense; Combined with website | 2 months | x | ||||
Mhurchu et al., 2014 | Weight management behavior | x | x | Ave. 2 motivational texts per day; 2 self-monitoring texts per week; Combined with hard-copy “toolkit” and website | 8 weeks; 4 week maintenance | xd | ||
Kramer et al., 2014 | Depression | x | 10 per day for 3 consecutive days per week; Weekly face-to-face feedback sessions | 6 weeks | x | x | ||
Cranwell et al., 2014 | Self-control | 3 per day | 4 weeks | X | ||||
Macias et al., 2015 | Psychiatric and physical well-being | x | X | 1 semiweekly, 1 weekly and 1 end of study assessment; Combined with texts, digital readings and videos | 4 weeks | X |
These studies were located by searching Pubmed.com, and publications from peer-reviewed journals listed in Scholar.google.com, up to November 27th, 2014 (search terms: “ecological momentary intervention” and “smartphone”).
Did not use controls.
Half of participants lost weight. However, there was no control group as this was an intervention feasibility study.
These results are from a small pilot, feasibility study.
A pre/post decrease in weight and body mass index (BMI) was observed but there was no control as this was mainly a feasibility study.