Table 1.
Comparison of MEC and runtimes for different schemes applied to HuRef data
chr # | Huref | |||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
CPLEX | SDhaP | HAPCUT | RefHap | HapTree | ||||||
MEC | t(in secs) | MEC | t(in secs) | MEC | t(in secs) | MEC | t(in secs) | MEC | t(in secs) | |
1 | 16853 | 1.72×105 | 17192 | 190 | 19777 | 251 | 18739 | 8354 | 21112 | 8499 |
2 | 12618 | 1260 | 12713 | 220 | 14698 | 185 | 13762 | 3576 | 15720 | 8210 |
3 | 9296 | 960 | 9444 | 153 | 10714 | 257 | 10096 | 4866 | 11424 | 12183 |
4 | 9958 | 1140 | 10106 | 115 | 11567 | 274 | 10936 | 5399 | 12479 | 9534 |
5 | 9195 | 1080 | 9333 | 141 | 10590 | 196 | 10045 | 4398 | 11391 | 8972 |
6 | 8637 | 900 | 8696 | 105 | 9922 | 247 | 9318 | 4225 | 10912 | 8462 |
7 | 9782 | 1020 | 9954 | 102 | 11279 | 152 | 10540 | 7030 | 12196 | 6876 |
8 | 8480 | 3960 | 8604 | 90 | 9832 | 226 | 9352 | 4640 | 10552 | 9162 |
9 | 8051 | 780 | 8134 | 88 | 9290 | 111 | 8850 | 3898 | 9905 | 5515 |
10 | 8550 | 1200 | 8680 | 87 | 9877 | 209 | 9323 | 5203 | 10598 | 8782 |
11 | 7027 | 840 | 7186 | 92 | 8210 | 156 | 7744 | 4514 | 8856 | 7093 |
12 | 7136 | 720 | 7256 | 100 | 8240 | 152 | 7725 | 2669 | 9003 | 5494 |
13 | 5090 | 600 | 5142 | 62 | 5844 | 125 | 5511 | 3363 | 6285 | 7680 |
14 | 5086 | 480 | 5173 | 52 | 5861 | 72 | 5537 | 2313 | 6273 | 3533 |
15 | 8088 | 1.67×105 | 8216 | 71 | 9364 | 108 | 9031 | 2014 | 10218 | 4018 |
16 | 7176 | 1500 | 7231 | 51 | 8287 | 138 | 7830 | 1896 | 8769 | 4589 |
17 | 5739 | 480 | 5819 | 47 | 6570 | 86 | 6238 | 2362 | 7106 | 5626 |
18 | 4403 | 540 | 4467 | 56 | 5041 | 108 | 4814 | 1542 | 5500 | 3544 |
19 | 4628 | 480 | 4670 | 32 | 5335 | 65 | 5052 | 1132 | 5660 | 2804 |
20 | 3243 | 300 | 3316 | 37 | 3753 | 63 | 3458 | 1472 | 4068 | 3602 |
21 | 3360 | 2400 | 3369 | 31 | 3914 | 63 | 3752 | 739 | 4154 | 1692 |
22 | 3908 | 7.16×105 | 3973 | 32 | 4539 | 43 | 4384 | 1786 | 4780 | 1683 |
MEC and running times for CPLEX, SDhaP, HAPCUT, RefHap and HapTree algorithms applied to HuRef data. SDhaP is more accurate than all schemes except for CPLEX (which is the only one that requires proprietary software). However, for longer blocks, the complexity of the CPLEX scheme may become very high as evident from chromosomes 1, 15 and 22.