Table 1.
Faculty ratings of resident performance for task-specific checklists and OSATS*
| Measure | LVH Mean (SD) |
Bowel Anastomosis Mean (SD) |
Pancreatico- jejunostomy Mean (SD) |
Mean Score Across Stations Mean(SD) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Task-specific checklists (%) correct | 61.1% (25.1%) | 86.1% (13.1%) | 82.3% (10.8%) | — |
| OSATS | ||||
| Respect for tissue | 4.67 (.82) | 3.58 (.80) | 4.00 (.63) | 4.08 (.84) |
| Time and motion | 4.17 (.41) | 3.83 (1.03) | 3.83 (.75) | 3.94 (.75)** |
| Knowledge of Instruments | 4.83 (.41) | 4.83 (.41) | 4.67 (.52) | 4.78 (.43)** |
| Use of assistants | 4.00 (.89) | 3.83 (.41) | 3.83 (.98) | 3.89 (.76) |
| Flow of operation and forward planning | 4.33 (.82) | 4.42 (.66) | 4.12 (.98) | 4.31 (.79) |
| Ability to adapt to individual pathological circumstances | 4.00 (.63) | 4.00 (0) | 4.12 (.41) | 4.06 (.42)** |
| Overall performance | 3.67 (1.03) | 4.08 (.66) | 3.75 (.88) | 3.83 (.84) |
*
Responses on a 5-point Likert scale from 1=very poor to 5=clearly superior
**
p < .05, Repeated measures ANOVA with follow up t-tests, Bonferonni correction for multiple pairwise comparisons