Skip to main content
. 2015 May 11;10(5):e0126587. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0126587

Table 2. Sensitivity analysis results.

Items Studies Sample size Tests for heterogeneity Analysis model Test for overall effect RR/WMD Favors
RA/GA I2 P* Z P* 95%CI
Operative Time(min) [714] 398/400 85% <0.00001 Random 2.63 0.009 -5.55 [-9.68,-1.41] RA
Tramadol demand(mg) [79,11,12,14] 345/344 96% <0.00001 Random 5.64 <0.00001 -59.68 [-80.41,-38.94] RA
Complications
IOH [8,11] 144/142 41% 0.19 Fixed 2.56 0.01 2.24 [1.21,4.15] GA
Nausea/Vomiting [8,1012,14] 318/318 0% 0.92 Fixed 4.23 <0.0001 0.39 [0.25,0.60] RA
Fever [8,11,12] 194/192 5% 0.35 Fixed 1.30 0.19 0.75 [0.48,1.16] RA
Blood Transfusion [913] 193/190 0% 0.85 Fixed 0.36 0.72** 0.90 [0.52,1.56] RA
Grade I POC [1012] 132/128 46% 0.16 Fixed 0.88 0.38 0.69 [0.30,1.58] RA
Grade II POC [1012] 132/128 0% 0.99 Fixed 0.56 0.58** 0.85 [0.48,1.50] RA
≥Grade III POC [11,12] 108/102 0% 0.78 Fixed 1.09 0.27** 0.44 [0.10,1.91] RA
Total POC [1012] 132/128 5% 0.35 Fixed 1.45 0.15 0.74 [0.49,1.11] RA
Hospital Stay(d) [810,12] 192/198 49% 0.12 Fixed 7.73 <0.00001 -0.59[-0.74,-0.44] RA
Stone-Free Rate [812] 234/182 0% 0.48 Fixed 0.42 0.68 1.02 [0.93,1.12] RA

RA: regional anesthesia GA: general anesthesia RR: relative risk WMD: weighted mean difference CI: confidence interval IOH: intraoperative hypotension POC: postoperative complications

* P<0.05 was considered statistically significant.

**originally significant before nRCTs excluded.