Table 1. Comparison of preclinical and clinical trials of progesterone in TBI.
Preclinical TBI [180] | Clinical TBI [24, 25, 50, 51] | |
---|---|---|
Injury type | Majority in open head injury with cavity formation (CCI or FPI model) [180]; a few in closed head injury (weight drop model) [181, 182] |
Blunt, closed head injury |
Injury severity | Mainly moderate, homogenous |
Severe only [25, 50] or moderate to severe [24, 51], heterogeneous |
Multiple trauma | TBI alone | 83% with multiple trauma [50] |
Traumatic
subarachnoid hemorrhage |
Not measured | 76%[50] |
Age | Mainly young adult | 16 to 94 years old, mainly young [24, 25, 50, 51] |
Sex | Mainly males | Mixed (male sex, 70-80% )[24, 25, 50, 51] |
Initial intervention
time |
Most < 1 hr | Average 3.6 - 6.3 hr [24, 25, 50, 51] |
Intervention
duration |
12 hr -14 days | 3 days [24], 4 days [51] or 5 days [25, 50] |
Outcome measures | Edema, lesion size, functional, cytokines |
GOS-E, DRS, mortality at 1, 3, 6 months |
Efficacy compared
to placebo |
Effective in majority of animal TBI trials [49, 183, 184]; Worse in female adolescence mice after CCI-TBI [185]; No effect on edema and lesion in rats after CCI-TBI [186] |
Favorable outcome in moderate TBI but not in severe TBI in a Phase II study [24]; Favorable outcome in severe TBI in a Phase II study [25]; No benefits in the Phase III studies [50, 51] |
Note: CCI=Controlled Cortical Impact, FPI=Fluid Percussion Injury; GCS = Glasgow Coma Scale, for classifying TBI severity; GOS = Glasgow Outcome Scale, as a common primary outcome measure in TBI; GOS-E=GOS-Extended (more sensitive than the GOS); DRS=Disability Rating Scale, for tracking the patient’s progress over time.