Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2016 Jun 1.
Published in final edited form as: Periodontol 2000. 2015 Jun;68(1):7–20. doi: 10.1111/prd.12091

Table 2.

Advantages and disadvantages of large animals defect models

Defect Type Animal Model Advantages Disadvantages
Furcation/infrabony periodontal defect Dog & Monkey Surgical Acute-chronic
  • short time to be created-less expensive

  • standardized morphological characteristics

  • do not regenerate spontaneously (chronic)

  • class II–III furcation

  • bilateral similar defect

  • horizontal defect allows an estimation of the origin of the newly formed tissue

  • solid database describing healing (dog)

  • minimal palatal recession (monkey)



Ligature-induced
  • microbiological features similar to humans

  • morphological features similar to humans

  • do not regenerate spontaneously

  • can make similar lesions as control in contralateral defects

Surgical Acute
  • do not reproduce inflammatory/infective conditions

  • spontaneous partial regeneration (monkey)

    Surgical Chronic

  • soft tissues compromised

  • variable amount of connective tissue regeneration



Ligature-induced
  • non-predictable disease development

  • non-standardized defect morphology (dog)

  • require time to be created & expensive

Alveolar socket Dog & Monkey
  • easy and fast to perform

  • reproduce well the events occurring in bone healing

  • rapid bone repair compared to human (dog)

Infrabony peri-implant defect Dog & Monkey Surgically created
  • short-time needed to be generated defect

  • standard morphology-dimension


Ligature-induced
  • morphological and microbiological similarities with humans

Surgically created
  • spontaneous regeneration


Ligature-induced
  • spontaneous partial regeneration

  • long time required to generate defect

Supra-alveolar peri-implant defect Dog
  • limited spontaneous regeneration

  • reproducibly created

  • requires space-providing devices

Reproduced from (95), with permission.