Table 3.
Standardised mean differences, d, in ninth grade test scores and teacher ratings, crude and adjusted for parental age and education, in mathematics, physics/chemistry, Danish and English by sex and co-twin sex for Danish twin and singleton females born 1986–1990. Positive values of d represent higher scores for males compared with females and/or opposite-sex twins compared with same-sex twins and/or opposite-/same-sex twins compared with singletons.
| Characteristic | Male/females (ref. female) | Adjusted | Opposite-sex/ same-sex females (ref. same-sex) | Adjusted | Opposite-sex/ singleton females (ref. singletons) | Adjusted | Same-sex/ singleton females (ref. singletons) | Adjusted |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mathematics — oral | ||||||||
| Test scores available | 16,727 | 15,589 | 2540 | 2377 | 6726 | 6243 | 7688 | 7158 |
| Effect size differencec | .07 | .06 | −.09 | −.13 | −.07 | −.13 | .01 | −.00 |
| 95% CId | (.04; .10)b | (.03; .09)b | (−.18; .00) | (−.21; −.04)a | (−.15; .00)a | (−.20; −.06)b | (−.05; .07) | (−.06; .06) |
| Teacher ratings available | 17,014 | 15,814 | 2565 | 2391 | 6840 | 6325 | 7817 | 7248 |
| Effect size differencec | −.02 | −.04 | −.08 | −.12 | −.06 | −.11 | .02 | .01 |
| 95% CId | (−.05; .01) | (−.07; −.01)a | (−.17; .01) | (−.20; −.03)a | (−.13; .01) | (−.18; −.03)a | (−.05; .08) | (−.05; .07) |
| Mathematics — written | ||||||||
| Test scores available | 16,777 | 15,627 | 2549 | 2383 | 6747 | 6254 | 7710 | 7171 |
| Effect size differencec | .17 | .15 | −.10 | −.14 | −.07 | −.14 | .02 | −.00 |
| 95% CId | (.14; .20)b | (.12; .18)b | (−.19; −.01)a | (−.23; −.05)a | (−.15; .00)a | (−.21; −.07)b | (−.04; .09) | (−.06; .06) |
| Teacher ratings available | 17,031 | 15,830 | 2570 | 2395 | 6849 | 6333 | 7827 | 7258 |
| Effect size differencec | −.01 | −.03 | −.08 | −.12 | −.07 | −.14 | .01 | −.01 |
| 95% CId | (−.05; .02) | (−.06; .00)a | (−.17; .01) | (−.21; −.03)a | (−.15; .00) | (−.21; −.06)b | (−.06; .07) | (−.07; .05) |
| Mathematics — neatness | ||||||||
| Test scores available | 13,086 | 12,168 | 1986 | 1857 | 5239 | 4835 | 6045 | 5600 |
| Effect size differencec | −.63 | −.64 | −.01 | −.02 | −.05 | −.08 | −.04 | −.05 |
| 95% CId | (−.67; −.60)b | (−.67; −.60)b | (−.11; .09) | (−.12; .08) | (−.13; .04) | (−.17; .01) | (−.10; .03) | (−.12; .02) |
| Teacher ratings available | 13,270 | 12,309 | 2002 | 1867 | 5307 | 4885 | 6129 | 5662 |
| Effect size differencec | −.71 | −.72 | −.08 | −.12 | −.05 | −.12 | .03 | .00 |
| 95% CId | (−.74; −68)b | (−.75; −.68)b | (−.19;.02) | (−.22; −.01)a | (−.14; .03) | (−.21; −.03)a | (−.04; .10) | (−.07; .07) |
| Physics/chemistry — Oral | ||||||||
| Test scores available | 13,381 | 12,483 | 2037 | 1915 | 5314 | 4922 | 6125 | 5695 |
| Effect size differencec | .00 | −.01 | −.07 | −.11 | −.05 | −.12 | .02 | −.00 |
| 95% CId | (−.04; .03) | (−.05; .02) | (−.18; .03) | (−.22; −.01)a | (−.14; .03) | (−.20; −.04)a | (−.05; .09) | (−.07; .07) |
| Teacher ratings available | 16,267 | 15,149 | 2486 | 2320 | 6557 | 6069 | 7501 | 6965 |
| Effect size differencec | −.01 | −.04 | −.06 | −.12 | .00 | −.06 | .06 | .05 |
| 95% CId | (−.04; .02) | (−.07; −.00)a | (−.16; .03) | (−.21; −.03)a | (−.07; .08) | (−.13; .01) | (−.00; .13) | (−.01; .11) |
| Danish — Oral | ||||||||
| Test scores available | 16,889 | 15,722 | 2581 | 2412 | 6825 | 6319 | 7810 | 7253 |
| Effect size differencec | −.33 | −.35 | .02 | −.03 | −.01 | −.08 | −.03 | −.04 |
| 95% CId | (−.36; −30)b | (−.38; −32)b | (−.07; .11) | (−.12; .06) | (−.08; .06) | (−.15; −.01)a | (−.09; .03) | (−.10; .02) |
| Teacher ratings available | 17,034 | 15,833 | 2581 | 2407 | 6861 | 6345 | 7844 | 7276 |
| Effect size differencec | −.44 | −.46 | .03 | −.01 | .03 | −.04 | −.00 | −.02 |
| 95% CId | (−.47; −41)b | (−.49; −43)b | (−.06; .13) | (−.10; .08) | (−.04; .10) | (−.11; .03) | (−.07; .06) | (−.08; .04) |
| Danish — Written | ||||||||
| Test scores available | 16,887 | 15,720 | 2583 | 2413 | 6829 | 6323 | 7806 | 7250 |
| Effect size differencec | −.48 | −.49 | .04 | −.02 | −.02 | −.09 | −.06 | −.07 |
| 95% CId | (−.51; −45)b | (−.52; −46)b | (−.05; .13) | (−.10; .07) | (−.10; .05) | (−.17; −.02)a | (−.12; .00) | (−13; −.01)a |
| Teacher ratings available | 17,033 | 15,831 | 2581 | 2407 | 6861 | 6345 | 7844 | 7276 |
| Effect size differencec | −.58 | −.60 | −.02 | −.06 | −.06 | −.13 | −.05 | −.07 |
| 95% CId | (−.61; −55)b | (−.63; −57)b | (−.11; .08) | (−.15; .03) | (−.14; .01) | (−.20; −.06)b | (−.11; .02) | (−.13; −.01)a |
| Danish — spelling | ||||||||
| Test scores available | 16,930 | 15,758 | 2591 | 2420 | 6846 | 6335 | 7827 | 7267 |
| Effect size differencec | −.31 | −.33 | −.02 | −.05 | −.03 | −.08 | −.02 | −.04 |
| 95% CId | (−.35; −28)b | (−.36; −30)b | (−.11; .08) | (−.14; .04) | (−.11; .04) | (−.16; −.01)a | (−.08; .04) | (−.10; .02) |
| Teacher ratings available | 17,023 | 15,827 | 2577 | 2405 | 6857 | 6342 | 7838 | 7273 |
| Effect size differencec | −.42 | −.43 | −.02 | −.06 | −.03 | −.08 | −.01 | −.03 |
| 95% CId | (−.45; −39)b | (−.46; −40)b | (−.11; .08) | (−.15; .03) | (−.11; .04) | (−.15; −01)a | (−.08; .05) | (−.09; .03) |
| Danish — Neatness | ||||||||
| Test scores available | 16,883 | 15,716 | 2582 | 2412 | 6828 | 6322 | 7804 | 7248 |
| Effect size differencec | −.44 | −.45 | −.01 | −.03 | −.04 | −.07 | −.03 | −.04 |
| 95% CId | (−.47; −41)b | (−.48; −41)b | (−.10; .08) | (−.12; .06) | (−.12; .03) | (−.15; .00) | (−.09; .03) | (−.10; .02) |
| Teacher ratings available | 17,019 | 15,819 | 2580 | 2406 | 6854 | 6338 | 7836 | 7268 |
| Effect size differencec | −.66 | −.67 | −.04 | −.07 | −.07 | −.11 | −.03 | −.04 |
| 95% CId | (−.69; −63)b | (−.70; −64)b | (−.13; .05) | (−.16; .02) | (−.14; .01) | (−.18; −03)a | (−.09; .04) | (−.10; .03) |
| English — oral | ||||||||
| Test scores available | 16,286 | 15,197 | 2485 | 2328 | 6574 | 6100 | 7529 | 7008 |
| Effect size differencec | −.18 | −.20 | .03 | −.03 | .01 | −.07 | −.02 | −.03 |
| 95% CId | (−.21; −15)b | (−.23; −17)b | (−.06; .13) | (−.12; .06) | (−.06; .09) | (−.15; .00) | (−.08; .04) | (−.09; .03) |
| Teacher ratings available | 16,851 | 15,682 | 2550 | 2380 | 6799 | 6291 | 7765 | 7209 |
| Effect size differencec | −.25 | −.27 | .03 | −.03 | .04 | −.05 | .01 | −.01 |
| 95% CId | (−.28; −22)b | (−.30; −.24)b | (−.07; .12) | (−.11; .06) | (−.04; .11) | (−.12; .03) | (−.05; .08) | (−.07; .05) |
p < 0.05.
p < 0.001.
In units of SD.
Confidence intervals.