Table 4.

One-day workshops: before and after training agreement between coders, coder agreement with expert consensus and confidence in BCT Identification

BCT number and label	Before training				After training
(BCTs ordered according to mean PABAK inter-coder agreement between trainees, after training)	N trainees identifying BCT (max = 109)	Mean PABAK agreement between trainees	Mean PABAK trainee agreement with expert consensus	% trainee identifications with high confidence ratings (i.e. ++)	N trainees identifying BCT (max = 109)	Mean PABAK agreement between trainees	Mean PABAK trainee agreement with expert consensus	% trainee identifications with high confidence ratings (i.e. ++)
2.3. Self-monitoring of behaviour	49	.49	−.10	22	101	.96	.85	88
2.2. Feedback on behaviour	56	.49	.03	57	93	.93	.71	92
8.1. Behavioural practice/rehearsal	81	.42	.49	80	98	.70	.80	90
10.3. Nonspecific reward	74	.48	.36	86	75	.56	.38	88
1.3. Goal setting (outcome)	60	.64	.22	89	84	.56	.54	87
10.2. Material reward (behaviour)	104	.56	.91	85	105	.48	.93	88
9.1. Credible source	68	.20	.25	57	75	.44	.38	87
1.2. Problem solving	82	.45	.50	89	71	.33	.30	89
6.1. Demonstration of the behaviour	76	.27	.39	89	100	.30	.83	93
5.1. Information about health consequences	86	.67	.58	91	77	.19	.41	87
1.1. Goal setting (behaviour)	86	.93	.58	89	62	.19	.14	78
3.1. Social support (unspecified)	89	.78	.63	86	47	−.11	−.13	94

BCT labels and numbers correspond to BCTTv1 (Michie et al. [12])