Table 2. The effect size across included studies.
Study | Year | exposure to waterfluoridation | RRs/HRs/ORs (95%CIs) |
---|---|---|---|
Simonen O | 1985 | 1.0 vs. 0–0.1mg/l | |
female | 1.5(1.2 to 1.8) | ||
male | 2.5(1.6 to 3.9) | ||
Sowers MF | 1991 | 4.0±0.1 vs. 1.0 mg/l | 2.2(1.1 to 4.7) |
Danielson C | 1992 | 1.0 vs. 0.3ppm | |
female | 1.27(1.08 to 1.46) | ||
male | 1.41(1.0 to 1.81) | ||
Jacobsen SJ | 1992 | nonfluoradated vs. fluoridated | |
female | 1.17(1.13 to 1.22) | ||
male | 1.08(1.06 to 1.1) | ||
Jacobsen SJ | 1993 | nonfluoradated vs. fluoridated | |
male | 0.78(0.37 to 1.66) | ||
female | 0.6(0.42 to 0.85) | ||
Cauley JA | 1995 | 1.01±0.21 vs. 0.15±0.10 mg/l | |
0 year | 1.0 | ||
1–10 years | 0.89(0.42 to 1.92) | ||
11–20years | 0.58(0.14 to 2.48) | ||
>20 years | 0.44(0.1 to 1.86) | ||
Karagas MR | 1996 | nonfluoradated vs. fluoridated | |
male | 1(0.92 to 1.09) | ||
female | 1.01(0.96 to 1.06) | ||
Lehmann R | 1998 | 0.77–1.20 vs. 0.08–0.36mg/l | |
male | |||
60–64 years | 2.14(0.89 to 5.2) | ||
65–69 years | 0.55(0.22 to 1.39) | ||
70–74 years | 0.78(0.27 to 1.39) | ||
75–79 years | 1.05(0.65 to 1.69) | ||
80–84 years | 1.02(0.67 to 1.55) | ||
≥80 years | 1.92(1.07 to 3.45) | ||
female | |||
60–64 years | 0.9(0.51 to 1.58) | ||
65–69 years | 1.56(1 to 2.44) | ||
70–74 years | 1.09(0.76 to 1.57) | ||
75–79 years | 1.38(1.06 to 1.8) | ||
80–84 years | 1.2(0.95 to 1.52) | ||
≥80 years | 1.41(1.1 to 1.81) | ||
Kurttio P | 1999 | female | |
≤0.10 mg/l | 1.0 | ||
0.11–0.30 mg/l | 0.93(0.84 to 1.02) | ||
0.31–0.50 mg/l | 1.12(0.93 to 1.34) | ||
0.51–1.00 mg/l | 1.12(0.96 to 1.31) | ||
1.10–1.50 mg/l | 1.08(0.88 to 1.32) | ||
>1.50 mg/l | 1.08(0.8 to 1.46) | ||
male | |||
≤0.10 mg/l | 1.0 | ||
0.11–0.30 mg/l | 1.05(0.9 to 1.22) | ||
0.31–0.50 mg/l | 0.72(0.51 to 1.02) | ||
0.51–1.00 mg/l | 1.03(0.81 to 1.32) | ||
1.10–1.50 mg/l | 0.67(0.46 to 0.97) | ||
>1.50 mg/l | 0.98(0.61 to 1.6) | ||
Phipps KR | 2000 | mixed exposure | 0.73(0.49 to 1.09) |
continuous exposure | 0.69(0.5 to 0.96) | ||
Hillier S | 2000 | ≥0.9 vs. <0.9mg/l | 1(0.7 to 1.5) |
Li Y | 2001 | 0.25–0.34 mg/l | 0.99(0.21 to 4.77) |
0.58–0.73 mg/l | 1.12(0.35 to 3.62) | ||
1.00–1.06 mg/l | 1.0 | ||
1.45–2.19 mg/l | 2.13(0.76 to 5.96) | ||
2.62–3.56 mg/l | 1.73(0.56 to 5.33) | ||
4.32–7.97 mg/l | 3.26(1.20 to 8.82) | ||
Park EY | 2008 | fluoridated vs. nonfluoradated | |
female | 0.88(0.77 to 1) | ||
male | 0.91(0.84 to 0.99) | ||
Näsman P | 2013 | Very low <0.3 | 1.0 |
Low 0.3–0.69 | 0.97(0.94 to 0.99) | ||
Mendium 0.7–1.49 | 0.97(0.94 to 1) | ||
High ≥1.5 | 0.98(0.93 to 1.04) |