Skip to main content
. 2015 May 28;10(5):e0126488. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0126488

Table 2. The effect size across included studies.

Study Year exposure to waterfluoridation RRs/HRs/ORs (95%CIs)
Simonen O 1985 1.0 vs. 0–0.1mg/l
female 1.5(1.2 to 1.8)
male 2.5(1.6 to 3.9)
Sowers MF 1991 4.0±0.1 vs. 1.0 mg/l 2.2(1.1 to 4.7)
Danielson C 1992 1.0 vs. 0.3ppm
female 1.27(1.08 to 1.46)
male 1.41(1.0 to 1.81)
Jacobsen SJ 1992 nonfluoradated vs. fluoridated
female 1.17(1.13 to 1.22)
male 1.08(1.06 to 1.1)
Jacobsen SJ 1993 nonfluoradated vs. fluoridated
male 0.78(0.37 to 1.66)
female 0.6(0.42 to 0.85)
Cauley JA 1995 1.01±0.21 vs. 0.15±0.10 mg/l
0 year 1.0
1–10 years 0.89(0.42 to 1.92)
11–20years 0.58(0.14 to 2.48)
>20 years 0.44(0.1 to 1.86)
Karagas MR 1996 nonfluoradated vs. fluoridated
male 1(0.92 to 1.09)
female 1.01(0.96 to 1.06)
Lehmann R 1998 0.77–1.20 vs. 0.08–0.36mg/l
male
60–64 years 2.14(0.89 to 5.2)
65–69 years 0.55(0.22 to 1.39)
70–74 years 0.78(0.27 to 1.39)
75–79 years 1.05(0.65 to 1.69)
80–84 years 1.02(0.67 to 1.55)
≥80 years 1.92(1.07 to 3.45)
female
60–64 years 0.9(0.51 to 1.58)
65–69 years 1.56(1 to 2.44)
70–74 years 1.09(0.76 to 1.57)
75–79 years 1.38(1.06 to 1.8)
80–84 years 1.2(0.95 to 1.52)
≥80 years 1.41(1.1 to 1.81)
Kurttio P 1999 female
≤0.10 mg/l 1.0
0.11–0.30 mg/l 0.93(0.84 to 1.02)
0.31–0.50 mg/l 1.12(0.93 to 1.34)
0.51–1.00 mg/l 1.12(0.96 to 1.31)
1.10–1.50 mg/l 1.08(0.88 to 1.32)
>1.50 mg/l 1.08(0.8 to 1.46)
male
≤0.10 mg/l 1.0
0.11–0.30 mg/l 1.05(0.9 to 1.22)
0.31–0.50 mg/l 0.72(0.51 to 1.02)
0.51–1.00 mg/l 1.03(0.81 to 1.32)
1.10–1.50 mg/l 0.67(0.46 to 0.97)
>1.50 mg/l 0.98(0.61 to 1.6)
Phipps KR 2000 mixed exposure 0.73(0.49 to 1.09)
continuous exposure 0.69(0.5 to 0.96)
Hillier S 2000 ≥0.9 vs. <0.9mg/l 1(0.7 to 1.5)
Li Y 2001 0.25–0.34 mg/l 0.99(0.21 to 4.77)
0.58–0.73 mg/l 1.12(0.35 to 3.62)
1.00–1.06 mg/l 1.0
1.45–2.19 mg/l 2.13(0.76 to 5.96)
2.62–3.56 mg/l 1.73(0.56 to 5.33)
4.32–7.97 mg/l 3.26(1.20 to 8.82)
Park EY 2008 fluoridated vs. nonfluoradated
female 0.88(0.77 to 1)
male 0.91(0.84 to 0.99)
Näsman P 2013 Very low <0.3 1.0
Low 0.3–0.69 0.97(0.94 to 0.99)
Mendium 0.7–1.49 0.97(0.94 to 1)
High ≥1.5 0.98(0.93 to 1.04)