Table 2.
Predicted versus experimental binding profiles for selected ligands from PSVLS. Lowest positive concentration refers to the lowest concentration tested that gave a positive response. Highest concentration tested refers to the highest concentration tested that gave a negative response. Inhibition results for aminopterin, desmosine, paclitaxel and fructose are from Dadgar et al.[19] and were obtained using FRET for 10 μM of each ligand against BoNT/A LC (10 nM). (+) indicates positive response, whereas (−) indicates negative response in the SPA binding assays.
| Compound Name | Computational Binding Preference (score)1 | BoNT/A LC | BoNT/A HC | Lowest Positive Concentration | Highest Negative Concentration | EC50 | % Inhibition at 10μM[19] |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aminopterin | R27 (−4.7) HC R8 (−4.8) HC R7 (−4.7) HC |
− | + | 1000 nM4 | 500nM3 | 703 nM | 11 |
| Desmosine | R6 (−5.5) LC R23 (−4.9) LC R10 (−4.8) HC R1 (−4.8) LC |
− | + | 2000 nM4 | 3000 nM3 | 1.6 μM | 25 |
| Solanesol | R6 (−6.0) LC | − | − | NA | 300 nM | NA | NA |
| Solanesyl pyrophosphate | R27 (−13.8) HC R3 (−13.4) HC R7 (−13.4) HC R2 (−12.9) LC R10 (−12.9) HC |
+ | + | 600 nM2 | NA | ND | NA |
| Paclitaxel | R14 (−11.0) LC | + | − | 50 nM | 50 nM | 17 nM | 95 |
| Fructose | R17(−1.9) HC | − | − | NA | 3000 nM | NA | 0 |
Score corresponds to holistic scores [19] at the best region(s) among the 33 regions scanned. Multiple regions are listed if the difference in binding energies was 1 unit or less. Scores not passing the per-region non-binder/binder threshold are shown in grey italic.
The lowest positive concentration of SolanesylPP was 600 nM for both BoNT/A HC and LC.
Ligands were tested at higher concentration against BoNT/A LC, producing a negative response; no lower concentrations were tested afterwards.
Positive ligands at higher concentration were tested against BoNT/A HC at two lower concentrations (250 nM and 50 nM), producing negative responses.
NA = not applicable; ND = not determined; LC = light chain, including the catalytic site among others; HC = heavy chain.