Skip to main content
. 2015 May 28;2015:1012.
Ref (type) Population Outcome, Interventions Results and statistical analysis Effect size Favours
Repetition of deliberate self-harm

Systematic review
People admitted to hospital after deliberate self-harm, 30%–100% with a previous history of deliberate self-harm
6 RCTs in this analysis
Repetition of deliberate self-harm 4 to 12 months
92/580 (16%) with intensive intervention
107/581 (18%) with treatment as usual

Peto OR 0.84
95% CI 0.62 to 1.15
P = 0.28
Not significant

RCT
1867 suicide attempters enrolled in the emergency departments of 5 participating sites (culturally diverse settings)
Further report of reference
Repeated suicide attempts 18 months
66/863 (7.6%) with brief intervention and contact
60/800 (7.5%) with usual care

Reported as not significant
P = 0.909
Not significant

RCT
243 people aged 11–69 years (mean age 31) with recent (within last 14 days) suicide attempts Proportion of participants with suicide re-attempts (based on hospital records) 1 year
20/123 (16%) with intensive intervention
13/120 (11%) with usual care

OR 1.60
95% CI 0.76 to 3.38
P = 0.22
Not significant

RCT
64 adults aged >18 years contacted within 3 days of presenting to hospital with an episode of self-harm Proportion of participants with self-harm repetition 12 months
11/32 (34%) with intensive intervention
4/32 (13%) with usual care

OR 3.67
95% CI 1.0 to 13.1
P = 0.046
Moderate effect size usual care
Suicide

RCT
1867 suicide attempters enrolled in the emergency departments of 5 participating sites (culturally diverse settings); median age 23 years Proportion of participants dying by suicide 18 months
2/872 (0%) with brief intervention and contact
18/827 (2%) with treatment as usual

P <0.001
Effect size not calculated brief intervention and contact

RCT
243 people aged 11–69 years (mean age 31) with recent (within last 14 days) suicide attempts Proportion of participants dying by suicide 1 year
1/123 (0.8%) with intensive intervention
0/120 (0%) with usual care

Not reported

RCT
64 adults aged >18 years contacted within 3 days of presenting to hospital with an episode of self-harm Proportion of participants dying by suicide 12 months
1/32 (3%) with intensive intervention
0/32 (0%) with usual care

Not reported
Admission to hospital

RCT
64 adults aged >18 years contacted within 3 days of presenting to hospital with an episode of self-harm Psychiatric hospital admissions 12 months
1/32 (3%) with intensive intervention
2/32 (6%) with usual care

Not reported