Table 1.
Area of Focus | Definition | Application to the SADE Study |
Applicability | How do the intended recipients, both targeted participants and those implementing the program, react to the intervention? | How do children with ASD and TD ages 6–12 respond to SADE? How do their parents and dental professionals react to the intervention? |
Demand | Do people in the target population see a need for the intervention? Are they willing to try it? | Results of prior research have indicated that children with ASD experience great difficulty receiving oral care at the dentist and that sensory sensitivities are associated with this difficulty (Stein, Polido, & Cermak, 2012, 2013; Stein, Polido, Mailloux, Coleman, & Cermak, 2011; Stein, Polido, Najera, & Cermak, 2012). |
Implementation | What is the extent to which, likelihood that, and manner in which an intervention can be fully implemented as planned and proposed? | The population at our recruitment site were largely Spanish-speaking Latinos. Latinos are underrepresented in medical research; there is not good evidence regarding whether this situation is due to their views on research, a lack of interest in participating, or barriers in recruitment methods. Moreover, the dental clinic reported a 30%–40% no-show rate; therefore, we were concerned about our ability to retain participants once recruited. Questions we addressed included
|
Practicality | To what extent can an intervention be delivered when resources, time, commitment, or some combination of these are constrained in some way? | What are the constraints of implementing the intervention in a large dental clinic in a children’s hospital? What will we need in terms of person hours for the consent process, verification of autism diagnosis, questionnaire completion, dental cleaning, and video analysis? Will adequate space (private room for dental cleaning) be available? Are there hospital policies or procedures that need to be considered to obtain approval to implement the intervention? |
Adaptation | Will procedures need to be changed to be appropriate in a new situation? It is important to describe the actual modifications that are made to accommodate the context and requirements of a different format, media, or population. | See description of SADE adaptations in Table 2. |
Integration | What level of system change will be needed to integrate a new program or process into an existing infrastructure? Will change in the organizational setting or the social or physical environment be necessary? | To what extent will the dental staff be willing to incorporate the SADE process into their daily routine? Can we work with the Cancer Research Informatics Core at the university’s cancer center to develop a database management system? |
Expansion | What is the potential for success of an already-successful intervention with a different population or in a different setting? | Our program was based on an application of SADE with young children with intellectual and developmental disabilities in a dental clinic in Israel (Shapiro, Melmed, Sgan-Cohen, & Parush, 2009). We wanted to examine its use in the United States with a different population. |
Limited-efficacy testing | Many feasibility studies are designed to test an intervention in a limited way such as with a convenience sample, with intermediate rather than final outcomes, with shorter follow-up periods, or with limited statistical power. | We used outcome measures, randomized controlled group assignment, and intervention procedures designed for our final study; however, we did use a smaller convenience sample.
|
Note. ASD = autism spectrum disorder; RCT = randomized controlled trial; SADE = sensory-adapted dental environment; TD = typically developing.