Table 3. Mycoplasma detection methods (Also refer to the studies by Uphoff et al (1992) and Tuly and Razin (1996)).
Method | Sensitivity | Specificity | Advantages | Disadvantages |
---|---|---|---|---|
Microbiological culture (selective broth and agar). | High | High | European Pharmacopeia recommended test. Gives a definitive result. | Requires specialist microbiology lab. Relatively slow. Potential source of cross-contamination. Some strains are non-culturable. |
Direct DNA stain, e.g. Hoechst 33 258 or DAPI | Low | Low (non-specific cytoplasmic DNA stains) | European Pharmacopeia recommended test. Rapid and cheap. | Reading and interpretation of test can be difficult and subjective. |
Indirect DNA stain, (using indicator cells e.g. 3T3 or 3T6) | High | Low (non-specific cytoplasmic DNA stains) | Amplifies contaminant so easier to interpret than direct stain. | Indirect therefore slower and more time consuming than direct stain. |
PCR, e.g., Universal Mycoplasma Kit1, Mycoplasma Plus2, MycoSensor2. | High | Medium (will not detect all Mycoplasma species) | Rapid and very sensitive. Several good commercial kits available. | False positives due to carry over contamination from positive controls and samples. False negatives due to PCR inhibitors in sample. |
Enzyme Linked Immunosorbant Assay (ELISA), e.g. MycoProbe3, Mycoplasma PCR ELISA4. | Medium (High if amplified ELISA) | Medium (will not detect all Mycoplasma species) | Rapid and cheap. Useful and simple for screening large numbers of samples. | Amplified ELISAs have additional stages and are slower. Requires access to ELISA spectrophotometer. |
Biochemical Detection, e.g. MycoAlert5. | Medium | High | Very rapid. Good for urgent testing of small sample numbers. | Requires access to a luminometer. |
ATCC (www.atcc.org).
Agilent Technologies (www.genomics.agilent.com).
R&D Systems (www.RnDSystems.com).
Roche (www.roche-applied-science.com).
Lonza (www.lonza.com).
Examples of commercial mycoplasma testing kits are provided for information only with no endorsement intended or implied.