Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2015 Jun 3.
Published in final edited form as: J Higher Educ. 2015 Mar-Apr;86(2):264–294. doi: 10.1353/jhe.2015.0009

Table 3. Sensitivity Analyses.

Average effect of affirmative action bans on the average first-time matriculation of underrepresented medical school students of color.

Public
(1)
Private
(2)
A. Main Results—Analytic Window 1993–2011 and all Comparison States
    BAN −0.032*** −0.028
(0.007) (0.022)
    No. of obs. 1029 723
    No. of institutions 64 42

B. Florida Excluded from Target States
    BAN −0.033*** −0.028
(0.007) (0.025)
    No. of obs. 1005 715
    No. of institutions 61 41

C. Narrower Subset of Comparison States
  1. Geographically Distant States
    BAN −0.031*** −0.029
(0.007) (0.022)
    No. of obs. 649 552
    No. of institutions 44 33
  2. Six Most Comparable States
    BAN −0.031*** −0.028
(0.008) (0.019)
    No. of obs. 516 343
    No. of institutions 37 21

D. Narrower Time Period (1996–2009)
   BAN −0.039** −0.024
(0.008) (0.022)
    No. of obs. 757 532
    No. of institutions 64 42

Note: All models include state fixed effects and a full set of institutional- and state-level covariates; institutional-level covariates include whether the medical school is research ranked (vs. primary care ranked); state-level covariates include percentage of population by race (White, Black, Native American, Latino, other), percentage of population with a bachelor’s degree, and percentage of 25–34 year olds unemployed. Models do not include year fixed effects to avoid collinearity with state-specific year trend. All models account for the clustering of observations within institution over time (with institutional random effects) and within state (with state fixed effects).