Skip to main content
. 2014 Nov 26;2014(11):CD008194. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD008194.pub3
Study Reason for exclusion
Aizer 2002 Modelling study using longitudinal data to evaluate multiple policies across multiple jurisdictions without controlling for potential confounders across jurisdictions
Aizer 2006 Modelling study using longitudinal data before and after interventions, but not available for re‐analysis
Atherly 2012 Retrospective cohort study
Bansak 2007 Modelling study using longitudinal data to evaluate multiple policies across multiple jurisdictions without controlling for potential confounders across jurisdictions
Barnett 2010 A retrospective, medical record review study
Bitran 2010 Post‐intervention description and lack of control
Bowblis 2008 Retrospective cohort study
Brown 2004 Post‐intervention description and lack of control
Buchmueller 2008 Post‐intervention description and lack of control
Buratto 2004 Post intervention description and lack of control
Card 2004 Time series study
Carter 2006 Longitudinal repeated measurements after interventions, but no measurements before interventions and no control group
Chen 2009 Cluster‐RCT, but only one site in each comparison group
Choi 2011 Retrospective cohort study
Cogan 2008 Not comparative, before‐after study
Cousineau 2007 Post‐intervention description and lack of control
Cousineau 2011 Non‐comparative, descriptive study
Currie 1996 Non‐comparative, descriptive study
Dave 2010 Time series from 1985 to 1996, no clear intervention time point
Davidoff 2005 Controlled before‐after study, but the baseline was very different between the treatment groups and comparison groups
Dutton 2000 Post‐intervention survey and lack of control
Frenk 2006 Longitudinal surveys and lack of control
Gardner 2008 Post‐intervention description and lack of control
Gordon 2001 Prospective observational study after intervention and no control group
Gresenz 2012 Post‐intervention description and lack of control
Guy 2010 Time series post‐intervention, no data before intervention
Hill 1993 Post‐intervention description and lack of control
Hill 2008 Analysed longitudinal data after intervention and lack of control
Jacobson 2007 Post‐intervention description and lack of control
Kenney 2010 Controlled before‐after study with only one intervention site
Kincheloe 2004 Cross‐sectional study
Lawler 2005 Post‐intervention descriptive study
Lee 2008 Modelling study using longitudinal data to evaluate multiple policy characteristics without controlling for possible confounding factors
Leininger 2007 Case‐control study
Lichtenstein 2005 Qualitative study
Lo Sasso 2004 Observational study, not comparative
Long 2007 Non‐comparative, descriptive study
Mahajan 2005 Post‐intervention description and absence of control
Meyer 2004 Qualitative study
Prado 2010 Before and after intervention in Colombia, but lack of control
Ray 2006 Qualitative study
Shore‐Sheppard 2000 Before and after intervention, but lack of control
Sieben 2000 Choice of control sites is not appropriate because there were significant baseline differences between participants from intervention and control sites for most characteristics, such as race/ethnicity, birthplace, language, employment status and baseline insurance coverage. The data are not enough for re‐analysis
Souares 2010 Before‐after study and absence of control
Thornton 2010 Before and after intervention, but lack of control
Wada 2006 Post‐intervention description and absence of control
Wolfe 2005 Analysed pool of 2‐year data to evaluate multiple insurance policy characteristics with potential confounding factors
Ziegenfuss 2008 Modelling study using longitudinal data before and after interventions, but not available for re‐analysis
Zimmer 2011 Time series study. Two data points before intervention, three data points after intervention