Table 6.
Rationale for waived patient consent in EPOCH
1 | Consent for routine documentation practice is implied with hospital admission + this is also true for other practices including staffing, ICU consultation, physician review |
+ Documentation is an inherent and routine part of hospital care | |
+ In intervention hospitals the BedsidePEWS becomes the accepted standard for documentation | |
+ In control hospitals and before implementation in hospitals randomized to implement BedsidePEWS, consenting to routine care in a situation where that there is no alternative is counter-intuitive | |
2 | Patient-level data are retrospectively obtained and + does not require patient contact |
+ does not require additional clinical investigation | |
+ precedent exists for waived consent for this type of data collection | |
3 | Preemptive consent for events (including in-hospital cardiac arrest, death) that have not occurred - and that may not occur |
+ Is potentially distressing to families | |
+ Is inefficient use of research resources | |
4 | Obtaining consent is not feasible for 100,000 patients anticipated in the study sample |
+ retrospective consent from families of deceased children may add burden and is potentially distressing to families | |
5 | Incomplete enrollment would undermine and bias the scientific validity of the study |
6 | Data will be presented in aggregate. |
No identifying information will leave the study office in the participating hospital |