Skip to main content
. 2013 Nov 6;86(4):313–317.

Table I.

Differences between hypertrophic and keloid scars.

Hypertrophic scar Keloid scar
Clinical appearance
  • Develops soon

  • Stays within the original scar boundary

  • Improves with time

  • Tends to flatten with time

  • Appears when scars cross joint, skin creases at a right angle

  • No association with skin color

  • May appear after months

  • Grows beyond the boundaries of the initial wound

  • Rarely improves, usually develops with time

  • Raised, firm, pruritic, painful

  • Do not spontaneously regress

  • Occurs on the ear lobe, sternal notch, shoulders, upper back, back of the neck, cheeks

  • Associated with dark skin

Histopathologhical
  • Collagen fibers oriented parallel to the long axis of the epidermal surface

  • Nodules of high density fibroblasts and collagen in the middle or deeper scar’s layer

  • Small blood vessels oriented vertically around the nodules

  • 20–30% mast cells in reticular dermis

  • “Keloid collagen” (thick and hyalinized collagen) arranged in a hazard pattern

  • Absence of nodules

  • Small blood vessels under die epidermis appearing to grow out in the scar

  • 73% mast cells in reticular dermis

Immunohistochemical
  • No α-SMA expressing myofibroblasts

  • α-SMA expressing myofibroblasts present in a third of cases

  • Higher CD4(+):CD8(+) ratio

Electron microscopic
  • The collagen fibers separated from the fibroblast’s membrane by a amorphous substance