Table 3.
Psychological stress and psychopathology affect GR gene methylation
| Study | Experimental Group |
Species | Sex (% male) |
Sample size | DNA Methylation Assessment | Tissue(s) | Age at Sample Collection |
16 | 17 | NGFI-A site? |
110 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Animal Studies | 1 Desarnaud et al. 2008 (22) | Social defeat and exposure to rat | Mouse | NR | 5 animals per group | Sodium bisulfite treatment (EZ DNA Methylation Kit, Zymo Research) + sequencing (ABI Prism 3100 Genetic Analyzer, Applied Biosystems) | Hippocampus | NR | no Δ a | Y | ||
| 2 Witzmann et al. 2012 (24) | Acute or chronic stress | Rat | 100 | 6 animals per group | Sodium bisulfite treatment (EpiTect Bisulphite kit, Qiagen) + pyrosequencing (Pyromark ID using Pyrogold reagents, Biotage) | Paraventricular nucleus (PVN) Hippocampus Adrenal Pituitary |
10–12-week-old | ↑b | Yc | |||
| 3 Tran et al. 2013 (50) | Repeated (7 day) water avoidance stress | Rat | 100 | 6 animals per group | Sodium bisulfite treatment (EZ DNA Methylation-Gold kit, Zymo Research) + pyrosequencing (EpigenDX) | Amygdala | Adult | ↑ | Y |
| Study | Experimental Group | Sex (% male) | Sample size | DNA Methylation Assessment | Tissue(s) | Age at Sample Collection | 1D | 1J | 1E | 1B | 1F | NGFI-A site? | 1C | 1H | Other | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Human Peripheral Studies | 4 De Rooij et al. 2012 (51) | Variations in acute stress reactivity | 47 | 675 | Methylation-sensitive enzymatic restriction (AciI and HinfI) + qPCR (SYBR Green, Sigma) | Blood | 55–60 | no Δs | ||||||||
| 5 Dammann et al. 2011 (52) | Borderline personality disorder | Control: 0 BPD: 8 |
Control: 11 BPD: 26 |
COBRA and/or Sodium bisulfite treatment + pyrosequencing (PyroMark Q24, Qiagen) | Blood | 33 | ↑ | N | ||||||||
| 6 Steiger et al. 2013 (21) | Bulimia nervosa with childhood abuse | 0 | BN with childhood abuse: 32 BN without childhood abuse: 32 No BN or abuse: 32 |
Sodium bisulfite treatment (EpiTect Bisulfite Kit, Qiagen) + EpiTYPER platform (Sequenom) | Blood | BN: 26.05 (mean) No eating disorder: 23.67 (mean) |
no Δ | no Δ | Y | ↑d | ↓e | |||||
| 7 Yehuda et al. 2013 (53) | Combat veterans with PTSD and prolonged exposure to psychotherapy: responders and non- responders | 88 | Responders: 8 Non-responders: 8 |
Sodium bisulfite treatment (EpiTect Bisulfite Kit, Qiagen)+ sequencing (Genewiz) | Blood | Responders: 41 Non-responders: 58 |
no Δ f | Y | ||||||||
| 8 Labonté et al. 2014 (55) | Post-traumatic stress disorder and negative trauma experience | 50 | PTSD: 30 Controls: 16 |
Sodium bisulfite treatment (EpiTect Bisulfite Kit, Qiagen) + Epityper (Sequenom) | Blood | PTSD: 43.4 Controls: 36.9 |
↓ | ↓ | no Δ | |||||||
| 9 Yehuda et al. 2014 (54) | Combat veterans with or without post-traumatic stress disorder | 100 | PTSD: 61 Controls: 61 |
Sodium bisulfite treatment (EpiTect Bisulfite Kit, Qiagen) + Sequencing (Genewiz) | Blood | PTSD: 34.2 Controls: 33.0 |
↓ | Y | ||||||||
| 10 Na et al. 2014 (56) | Major Depression Disorder | MDD: 24 Controls: 29 |
Total: 117 MDD: 45 Controls: 72 |
Sodium bisulfite treatment (EZ DNA Methylation-Gold kit, Zymo Research) + Pyrosequencing (Pyromark ID, Varionostic) | Blood | 18–65 MDD: 41.6 (median) Controls: 40.72 (median) |
↓g | Y | ||||||||
| Human Central Studies | 11 Alt et al. 2010 (30) | Lifetime diagnosis of major depressive disorder | MDD: 67 Controls: 50 |
MDD: 6 Controls: 6 |
Sodium bisulfite treatment (EpiTect Bisulfite Kit, Qiagen) + Pyrosequencing (Pyromark ID, Varionostic) | Amygdala Hippocampus Inferior prefrontal gyrus Cingulate gyrus Nucleus accumbens |
MDD: 75.5 Controls: 72.5 |
no Δs | no Δs | no Δs | no Δs | Y |
no detectable methylation on NR3C1 CpGs.
Acute stress group – ↑ methylation at several CpG sites in hippocampus only; Chronic stress group – ↑ methylation in response to psychosocial stress in adrenal and pituitary, ↑ methylation in adrenal and ↓ methylation in the pituitary in response to restraint stress.
Acute stress – hippocampus only; Chronic stress – adrenal only.
CpGs 10 & 21; BN vs. no eating disorder.
In BN+BPD vs. BN no BPD/no eating disorder.
No change over time and no difference between responders and non-responders.
CpGs 3 & 4.