Skip to main content
. 2013 Dec 9;2013(12):CD008846. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD008846.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Abraham 1944 Inadequate treatment dose
Afridi 1959 Inadequate treatment dose
Ahorlu 2009 Treatment not administered to entire population; intermittent preventive treatment for children (IPTc) study
Ahorlu 2011 Treatment not administered to entire population; intermittent preventive treatment for children (IPTc) study
Aikins 1993 Inadequate treatment dose; knowledge, attitudes, and prevention component of an individually randomized study
Alicata 1955 Inadequate treatment dose; individually randomized study
Aliev 2000 Inadequate treatment dose
Aliev 2001 Inadequate treatment dose
Allen 1990 Inadequate treatment dose
Alonso 1993a Inadequate treatment dose; individually randomized study
Alonso 1993b Inadequate treatment dose; individually randomized study
Alving 1952 Individually randomized study; study participants did not remain in endemic area
Amangel'diev 2001 Inadequate treatment dose; testing conducted prior to treatment; insufficient information on drug administration
Annual Report 1932 Inadequate treatment dose
Archambeault 1954 Study participants did not remain in endemic area
Archibald 1956 Individually randomized study
Babione 1966 Insufficient information on drug administration
Banerjea 1949 Inadequate treatment dose
Barber 1932 Inadequate treatment dose
Barger 2009 Individually randomized study
Baukapur 1984 Insufficient information on drug administration
Berberian 1948 Testing conducted prior to treatment
Berny 1936 Inadequate treatment dose
Bloch 1982 Insufficient information on drug administration
Bojang 2009 Insufficient information on outcomes reported
Bojang 2010 Individually randomized study
Bojang 2011 Insufficient information on outcomes reported
Boulanger 2009 Individually randomized study
Boulanger 2010 Individually randomized study
Brink 1958 Inadequate treatment dose
Butler 1943 Insufficient information on drug administration
Canet 1936 Inadequate treatment dose
Canet 1939 Insufficient information on outcomes reported
Canet 1949 Insufficient information on drug administration; insufficient information on outcomes reported (no outcome of interest reported)
Canet 1952 Inadequate treatment dose
Canet 1953 Inadequate treatment dose
Capponi 1953 Inadequate treatment dose
Celli 1914 Insufficient information on drug administration
Charles 1958 Individually randomized study; testing conducted prior to treatment
Charles 1960 Inadequate treatment dose
Charles 1962 Inadequate treatment dose
Chaudhuri 1950 Inadequate treatment dose
Chen 1999 Insufficient information on outcomes reported; treatment not administered to entire population
Cisse 2006 Individually randomized study
Cisse 2009 Treatment not administered to entire population; intermittent preventive treatment for children (IPTc) study
Ciuca 1937 Mixed curative and prophylactic dosing
Clark 1942 Testing conducted prior to treatment
Clarke 2008 Treatment not administered to entire population; intermittent preventive treatment for children (IPTc) study
Clyde 1958 Insufficient information on drug administration
Clyde 1961a Insufficient information on outcomes reported
Clyde 1961b Insufficient information on outcomes reported
Clyde 1962 Inadequate treatment dose
Coutinho 1962 Inadequate treatment dose
D'Anfreville 1930 Insufficient information on drug administration; insufficient information on outcomes reported (no outcome of interest reported)
Danquah 2009 Individually randomized study
Dapeng 1996 Insufficient information on drug administration; insufficient information on outcomes reported
de Mello 1938 Inadequate treatment dose
Decourt 1935 Inadequate treatment dose; individually randomized study
Decourt 1936 Inadequate treatment dose
Delmont 1981 Inadequate treatment dose; individually randomized study
Desowitz 1987 Insufficient information on drug administration
Diallo 1977 Inadequate treatment dose
Diallo 1983 Treatment not administered to entire population; intermittent preventive treatment in children (IPTc) study
Dicko 2008 Individually randomized study; testing conducted prior to treatment
Dicko 2011 Individually randomized study
Dixon 1950 Inadeqaute treatment dose
Doi 1989 Individually randomized study; testing conducted prior to treatment
Dola 1974 Inadequate treatment dose
Doucet 1947 Inadequate treatment dose
Downs 1946 Study participants did not remain in endemic area
Dupoux 1937 Insufficient information on outcomes reported
Dupoux 1939 Inadequate treatment dose
Edeson 1957 Inadequate treatment dose
Farinaud 1934 Insufficient information on drug administration
Farinaud 1950 Inadequate treatment dose
Gaud 1949 Inadequate treatment dose
Gilroy 1952 Inadequate treatment dose
Gomez Mendoza 1960 Insufficient information on outcomes reported
Gribben 1933 Inadequate treatment dose
Gruer 1962 Insufficient information on drug administration; insufficient information on outcomes of interest
Gunther 1951 Inadequate treatment dose
Gunther 1952 Mixed curative and prophylactic dosing
Gusmao 1970 Inadequate treatment dose; individually randomized study
Han 2006 Inadequate treatment dose
Harwin 1973 Individually randomized study
Henderson 1934 Mixed curative and prophylactic dosing
Ho 1965 Insufficient information on outcomes reported (no outcome of interest reported)
Houel 1954b Treatment not administered to entire population (children only)
Huehne 1971 Post‐only outcomes reported
Janssens 1950 Inadequate treatment dose
Joncour 1956 Inadequate treatment dose
Kaneko 2010 Insufficient information on drug administration; insufficient information on outcomes reported.
Karimov 2008 Inadequate treatment dose
Kingsbury 1931 Inadequate treatment dose
Klopfer 1949 Inadequate treatment dose
Komp 1935 Testing conducted prior to treatment
Konate 2011 Individually randomized study
Kweku 2008 Individually randomized study
Kweku 2009 Insufficient information on outcomes reported; comparison of delivery strategies; treatment not administered to entire population (both arms included intermittent preventive treatment in children (IPTc))
Lacroix 1952 Inadequate treatment dose
Lahon 1960 Inadequate treatment dose
Laing 1970 Testing conducted prior to treatment
Laing 1984 Inadequate treatment dose
Lakshmanacharyulu 1968 Insufficient information on drug administration
Levenson 1943 Mixed curative and prophylactic dosing
Liljander 2010 Individually randomized study
Lui 1986 Mixed curative and prophylactic dosing
Lysenko 1960 Mixed curative and prophylactic dosing
MacCormack 1983 Inadequate treatment dose
Mackerras 1954 Inadequate treatment dose
Maiga 2009 Individually randomized study
Malaria_Army 1934 Inadequate treatment dose; insufficient information on outcomes reported
Mason 1973 Insufficient information on drug administration
Mason 1977 Insufficient information on drug administration
Mastbaum 1957a Inadequate treatment dose
Mastbaum 1957b Inadequate treatment dose
McGregor 1966 Individually randomized study; testing conducted prior to treatment
Melik‐Adamian 1938 Testing conducted prior to treatment
Mendez Galvan 1984 Insufficient information on drug administration; insufficient information on outcomes reported
Mercier 1953 Inadequate treatment dose
Merle 1955 Inadequate treatment dose; treatment not administered to entire population (eg intermittent preventive treatment for children (IPTc))
Mezincesco 1935 Inadequate treatment dose
Miller 1955 Inadequate treatment dose; individually randomized study; treatment not administered to entire population
Monteny 1960 Inadequate treatment dose
Mühlens 1913 Insufficient information on drug administration; insufficient information on outcomes of interest
Nakibuuka 2009 Individually randomized study; testing conducted prior to treatment
Nankabirwa 2010 Individually randomized study
Nave 1973 Insufficient information on outcomes reported
Norman 1952 Inadequate treatment dose; insufficient information on outcomes of interest
Ntab 2007 Individually randomized study; insufficient information on outcomes reported
Omer 1978 Inadequate treatment dose
Onori 1972 Inadequate treatment dose
Ossi 1967 Insufficient information on outcomes reported
Ouedraogo 2010 Individually randomized study
Parrot 1937 Inadequate treatment dose
Parrot 1943 Inadequate treatment dose
Parrot 1944 Inadequate treatment dose
Parrot 1946 Inadequate treatment dose
Peters 1962 Inadequate treatment dose
Phillips 1954 Inadequate treatment dose
Pikul 1934 Insufficient information on outcomes reported
Pribadi 1986 Inadequate treatment dose
Prokopenko 1945 Inadequate treatment dose
Rachou 1965 Inadequate treatment dose
Rafi 1951 Inadequate treatment dose
Ray 1948 Inadequate treatment dose
Robin 1946 Testing conducted prior to treatment
Rodríguez 1994 Testing conducted prior to treatment
Rohner 2010 Individually randomized study
Saarinen 1987 Mixed curative and prophylactic dosing
Salako 1990 Individually randomized study; testing conducted prior to treatment
Salihu 2000 Inadequate treatment dose
Santos 1993 Inadequate treatment dose
Schliessmann 1973 Insufficient information on outcomes reported
Schneider 1948a Inadequate treatment dose
Schneider 1948b Inadequate treatment dose
Schneider 1958 Inadequate treatment dose
Schneider 1962 Individually randomized study; treatment not administered to entire population (eg intermittent preventive treatment for children (IPTc))
Seckinger 1935 Inadequate treatment dose
Sehgal 1968 Insufficient information on drug administration
Sergent 1913 Inadequate treatment dose; insufficient information on outcomes reported
Sesay 2011 Individually randomized study
Shanks 1992 Inadequate treatment dose; individually randomized study; testing conducted prior to treatment
Shanks 1993 Individually randomized study; study participants did not remain in endemic area
Shanks 1995a Inadequate treatment dose; study participants did not remain in endemic area
Shanks 1995b Study participants did not remain in endemic area
Sheinker 1945 Testing conducted prior to treatment
Singh 1968 Insufficient information on outcomes reported
Snowden 2006 Insufficient information on drug administration; insufficient information on outcomes reported
Sokhna 2008 Individually randomized study
Sorel 1913 Insufficient information on drug administration
Srivastava 1950 Inadequate treatment dose
Strangeways‐Dixon 1950 Inadequate treatment dose
Strickland 1986 Testing conducted prior to treatment
Swellengrebel 1931 Inadequate treatment dose
Tagbor 2011 Treatment not administered to entire population; intermittent preventive treatment for children (IPTc) study
Tine 2011 Treatment not administered to entire population; intermittent preventive treatment for children (IPTc) study
Turner 1977 Insufficient information on outcomes reported
Usenbaev 2006 Insufficient information on drug administration
Usenbaev 2008 Insufficient information on drug administration
Van Dijk 1958 Inadequate treatment dose
Van Goor 1950 Inadequate treatment dose
Verhoef 2002 Individually randomized study
Villegas 2010 Testing conducted prior to treatment
Wallace 1936 Mixed curative and prophylactic dosing
Wallace 1954 Insufficient information on drug administration
Watkins 1987 Individually randomized; mixed curative and prophylactic dosing
White 1934 Inadequate treatment dose
White 1937 Mixed curative and prophylactic dosing
Winter 1934 Insufficient information on outcomes reported
Wone 1967 Inadequate treatment dose
Yip 1998 Insufficient information on outcomes reported