Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2016 Jul 1.
Published in final edited form as: Psychol Bull. 2015 Apr 27;141(4):858–900. doi: 10.1037/a0038498

Table 5. Summary of Characteristics in Studies Examining the Incremental Validity of a Multi-Informant Approach to the Assessment of Mental Health.

Descriptive Information Informants Examined for Incremental Validity Criterion Measures Contextual Variations in Assessed Behavior

Mental Health Domain Author Group (year) Informants Use of the Same Measure Format to Gather Informants' Reports Information Sources Used for Criterion Measures Criterion Independent from Informants Examined for Incremental Validity Objective Criterion Used a Independent Assessment of Prevalence of Contextual Variations in Participants' Behavior
ADHD Power et al. (1998) P, T Combined diagnostic interview and T report X X X
Smith, Pelham, Gnagy, Molina, & Evans (2000) C, T / Independent observers X

ADHD subtypes and ODD Owens & Hoza (2003) P, T P, T X X X

Anxiety Villabø, Gere, Torgersen, March, & Kendall (2012) C, P Diagnostic interview X X X

Bipolar Disorder Youngstrom et al. (2004a) C, P, T / Diagnostic interview X X X

ODD Angold & Costello (1996) C, P Diagnostic interview; P and C interview reports of impairment, parental burden, and service use X X X

Relational Adjustment Ladd & Kochenderfer-Ladd (2002) C, P, T, Peer / C, P, T, Peer X X X

Social Skills and Academic Competence Kwon, Kim, & Sheridan (2012) T, Peer X C, T, Peer / X X

Note. ✓ = study utilized characteristic described by column header; / = study utilized characteristic described by column header for some but not all measures; X = study did not utilize characteristic described by column header. C = Child; P = Parent; T = Teacher. ADHD = Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder; ODD = oppositional defiant behaviors.

a

criterion based on objective measure (e.g., record reviews, behavioral observations, or behavioral measures).