Table 1.
Treatment | Description | Advantages | Disadvantages |
---|---|---|---|
Pressure therapy | Application of elastic bandages or pressure garments to apply pressure to scar sites. | Noninvasive. Can be applied at home by the patient. | Often cause discomfort to the wearer which affects compliance. To achieve optimum results from pressure therapy require 6–12 months constant wear. |
Silicone gel therapy | Application of silicone gel sheets or gel formulated in a tube. | Noninvasive. Can be applied at home by the patient. | To achieve optimum results from silicone gel therapy require 6–12 months constant wear. |
Steroid injections | Injection of corticosteroids directly into the scar tissue which inhibits fibrosis and reduces the number of contractile myofibroblasts. | Can inhibit the formation of hypertrophic scarring. | Requires multiple injections over a period of time to be administered by a clinician. |
Dermal fillers | Fillers such as collagen can be injected at the scar site. | Can be used to improve the contours of pitted scars. | Must be carried out by a cosmetic/healthcare professional. Results are temporary. |
Dermabrasion | Controlled abrasion or planing of upper to mid skin layers. This technique has largely been replaced with advanced methods such as laser resurfacing. | Can smooth raised scars and reduce shallow/mid-depth acne scars. | Invasive procedure which usually requires an anesthetic. The resultant wounds also carry the risk of further scar formation. |
Microdermabrasion | A cosmetic procedure involving the exfoliation of the skin epidermis. | Noninvasive, nonsurgical and usually pain-free technique. | Usually only effective on shallow scars such as those caused by acne. |
Laser resurfacing | The use of intense pulsed light typically with an erbium or CO2 laser. | Can reduce the elevation of scars and also soften scar tissue. | Must be carried out by a cosmetic/healthcare professional. Depending on the laser used, results can be short or long term. |
Skin grafts (punch grafts) | Small skin grafts are taken from unscarred skin and used to cover a scar. | Most commonly used for deeper acne scarring. | An invasive technique which requires additional wounds to be created to harvest skin tissue. |
Surgical revision | Can be used to improve the appearance of prominent, irregular-shaped scars. | An invasive surgical technique that requires often deep wounds to be created and which will form a further scar. | |
Ablative fractional resurfacing | A series of patients who experienced rapid and sustained healing of long-standing erosions and ulcers associated with traumatic scars and split-thickness skin grafts after initiating a course of AFR. | Advantages include the novel concept of photomicrodebridement, including biofilm disruption and the stimulation of de novo growth factor secretion and collagen remodeling. |
AFR, ablative fractional resurfacing.