Table 1.
Published open and arthroscopic labral reconstruction outcomes.
| Study | Open vs arthroscopic/graft | n | Sex | Age | Follow-up | Convert to THA | Preoperative outcome | Postoperative outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sierra and Trousdale (20) | Open/ligamentum teres capitis autograft | 5 | 3 M, 2 F | 33 (19–50) years | 10 (5–20) months | 1 (20%) | – 3 “severe pain” – 2 “moderately severe pain” – UCLA:5 (2– 6) |
– 3 “no pain” – 1 “moderate pain” – 1 “same pain as preoperatively” – UCLA: 8 (6–10) |
| Walker et al. (23) | Open/ligamentum teres capitis autograft or fascia lata autograft | 20 | 5 M, 14 F | 29 (16–50) years | 26 (12–56) months | 3 (15%) | Not reported | – UCLA: 8.5 (5–10) |
| White et al. (38) | Arthroscopic/iliotibial band allograft | 152 | 64 M, 78 F | 39 (16–58) years | 28 (24–39) months | 13 (10%) | – MHHS: 54 – LEFS: 41 – VAS rest: 5 – VAS ADLs: 6 – VAS sport: 8 |
– MHHS: 88 – LEFS: 68 – VAS rest: 2 – VAS ADLs: 2 – VAS sport: 3 – Satisfaction: 9/10 |
| Philippon et al. (18) | Arthroscopic/iliotibial band autograft | 47 | 32 M, 15 F | 37 (18–55) years | 18 (12–32) months | 4 (9%) | – MHHS: 62 | – MHHS: 85 – Satisfaction: 8/10 |
| Geyer et al. (25) | Arthroscopic/iliotibial band autograft | 76 | 42 M, 33 F | 39 (18–64) years | 49 (36–70) months | 18 (24%) + 1 (1%) resurface | – MHHS: 59 – HOS-ADL: 69 – HOS-Sport: 41 – SF-12 physical:42 – SF-12 mental:55 |
– MHHS: 83 – HOS-ADL: 81 – HOS-Sport: 67 – SF-12 physical: 50 – SF-12 mental: 53 – Satisfaction: 8/10 |
| Boykin et al. (24) | Arthroscopic/iliotibial band autograft | 21 | 19 M, 0 F | 28 (19–41) years | 41 (20–74) months | 2 (10%) | – MHHS: 67 – HOS-ADL: 77 – HOS-Sport: 56 – SF-12 physical: 44 – SF-12 mental: 49 |
– MHHS: 84 – HOS-ADL: 85 – HOS-Sport: 77 – SF-12 physical: 51 – SF-12 mental: 54 – Satisfaction: 8/10 – Returned to play: 18 (86%) |
| Matsuda and Burchette (26) | Arthroscopic/gracilis autograft | 8 | 7 M, 1 F | 35 (18–58) years | 30 (24–37) months | 0 (0%) | – NAHS: 42 | – NAHS: 92 – Satisfaction: 7 “high,”1 “moderate” |
| Domb et al. (39) | Arthroscopic/gracilis tendon autograft | 11 | 7 M, 4 F | 33 (18–45) years | 26 (24–32) months | 0 (0%) | – NAHS: 53 – HOS-ADL: 59 – HOS-Sport: 39 – MHHS: 55 – VAS: 7 |
– NAHS: 78 – HOS-ADL: 80 – HOS-Sport: 60 – MHHS: 82 – VAS: 3 – Satisfaction: 8/10 |
aData are expressed as count (%) or mean (range).
MHHS, modified harris hip score; HOS-ADL, hip outcome score-activities of daily living; HOS-sport, hip outcome score-sports-specific subscale; SF-12 physical, short form-12 physical component; SF-12 mental, short form-12 mental component; NAHS, non-arthritic hip score; VAS, visual analog scale for pain; ADLs, activities of daily living.