Skip to main content
. 2015 Jul 2;10(7):e0131011. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0131011

Table 4. Averages and SD for parameters of RecFem and Adds in all sessions, and ICC, CI, SEM and MDC for intra- and inter-rater reliability.

Muscle / Parameters Test-Retest Mean (SD) ICC SEM (SEM%) MDC (MDC%)
RecFem IntraWS rep. 1 IntraWS rep. 2 IntraWS rep. 3 InterWS rater 1 InterWS rater 2 IntraBS session 1 IntraBS session 2 IntraWS InterWS IntraBS IntraWS InterWS IntraBS IntraWS InterWS IntraBS
Vmax LV (°/s) 18.77 (±5.43) 19.48 (±7.82) 18.75 (±4.16) 15.57 (±2.41) 15.62 (±3.87) 19.09 (±5.64) 19.42 (±7.34) 0.94 0.40 0.89 2.40 (12.64) 2.89 (18.53) 2.95 (15.34) 5.56 (29.25) 6.70 (42.94) 6.85 (35.56)
Vmax HV (°/s) 265.7 (±45.81) 247.78 (±31.19) 252.72 (±31.71) 238.85 (±43.99) 242.13 (±52.37) 254.9 (±32.19) 244.42 (±28.54) 0.84 0.94 0.54 21.52 (8.42) 16.42 (6.83) 24.13 (9.66) 49.91 (19.53) 38.09 (15.83) 55.97 (22.41)
ROMLV (°) 88.85 (±11.59) 86.73 (±10.00) 88.74 (±9.69) 91.34 (±15.28) 90.17 (±14.91) 88.61 (±10.31) 90.41 (±16.06) 0.96 0.91 0.90 3.21 (3.63) 6.21 (6.84) 5.68 (6.34) 7.44 (8.44) 14.41 (15.87) 13.18 (14.72)
ROMHV (°) 88.51 (±8.93) 90.37 (±9.90) 90.01 (±8.61) 93.24 (±13.51) 92.88 (±11.74) 89.73 (±8.53) 91.9 (±10.30) 0.96 0.93 0.73 2.65 (2.96) 4.64 (4.99) 6.23 (6.86) 6.14 (6.85) 10.77 (11.57) 14.46 (15.92)
MVIC (mV) NA NA NA NA NA 0.142 (±0.09) 0.147 (±0.08) NA NA 0.63 NA NA 0.06 (46.99) NA NA 0.15 (103.52)
rms-EMG HV-LV (%) NA NA NA 21.27 (±20.50) 17.7 (±16.44) 19.91 (±15.05) 23.07 (±19.47) NA 0.97 0.86 NA 3.27 (16.81) 8.79 (40.93) NA 7.60 (38.99) 20.40 (94.91)
rms-EMG HV-LV (mV) NA NA NA 0.02 (±0.033) 0.02 (±0.027) 0.027 (±0.033) 0.027 (±0.031) NA 0.98 0.98 NA 0.004 (18.57) 0.005 (18.65) NA 0.01 (37.63) 0.01 (36.58)
Torque HV-LV (Nm) NA NA NA 13.19 (±8.90) 12.03 (±7.44) 12.84 (±9.77) 12.92 (±9.26) NA 0.96 0.98 NA 2.22 (17.66) 1.74 (13.54) NA 5.16 (40.90) 4.04 (31.34)
Work HV-LV (J) NA NA NA 9.73 (±5.15) 8.74 (±4.79) 9.09 (±6.93) 8.91 (±5.72) NA 0.97 0.95 NA 1.04 (11.27) 1.90 (21.17) NA 2.41 (26.08) 4.42 (49.09)
AOC (%) NA NA NA 74.10 (±16.11) 76.93 (±20.14) 77.66 (±16.32) 78.87 (±15.71) NA 0.64 0.86 NA 13.73 (18.18) 8.23 (10.51) NA 31.84 (42.16) 19.09 (24.39)
MLV (%/s) 43.24 (±6.80) 40.63 (±6.27) 38.64 (±6.66) 41.53 (±8.41) 37.9 (±7.36) 40.64 (±5.74) 40.06 (±4.83) 0.80 0.95 0.94 3.98 (9.75) 2.81 (7.07) 4.19 (10.39) 9.23 (22.59) 6.52 (16.41) 9.72 (24.08)
Adds
Vmax LV (°/s) 11.05 (±3.20) 11.01 (±2.56) 11.71 (±2.88) 11.24 (±3.67) 10.78 (±3.61) 11.27 (±2.71) 11.51 (±4.02) 0.85 0.61 0.28 1.72 (15.32) 2.80 (25.50) 3.22 (28.26) 3.98 (35.34) 6.51 (59.09) 7.47 (65.53)
Vmax HV (°/s) 93.09 (±21.88) 105.19 (±25.15) 99.51 (±27.71) 96.48 (±28.35) 84.36 (±21.33) 98.72 (±22.20) 83.77 (±22.25) 0.90 0.69 0.74 11.52 (11.61) 16.03 (17.73) 10.96 (12.01) 26.71 (26.90) 37.19 (41.12) 25.42 (27.85)
ROMLV (°) 34.63 (±10.66) 35.31 (±10.91) 37.01 (±10.09) 35.89 (±7.78) 32.54 (±6.59) 36.16 (±11.12) 33.36 (±6.16) 0.96 0.68 0.47 3.31 (9.28) 4.72 (13.80) 7.53 (21.66) 7.67 (21.51) 10.95 (31.99) 17.47 (50.25)
ROMHV (°) 33.06 (±6.99) 36.00 (±7.85) 35.40 (±10.35) 33.86 (±7.58) 30.76 (±8.72) 34.77 (±8.18) 30.66 (±7.57) 0.93 0.82 0.77 3.24 (9.31) 4.19 (12.99) 4.21 (12.87) 7.51 (21.56) 9.73 (30.11) 9.76 (29.82)
MVIC (mV) NA NA NA NA NA 0.096 (±0.063) 0.104 (±0.083) NA NA 0.91 NA NA 0.02 (29.81) NA NA 0.06 (59.83)
rms-EMG HV-LV (%) NA NA NA 8.61 (±4.63) 7.89 (±6.74) 9.02 (±4.99) 7.05 (±5.57) NA 0.79 0.78 NA 3.51 (42.65) 2.99 (37.22) NA 8.16 (98.87) 6.94 (86.30)
rms-EMG HV-LV (mV) NA NA NA 0.007 (±0.004) 0.006 (±0.005) 0.007 (±0.004) 0.005 (±0.004) NA 0.81 0.86 NA 0.003 (44.90) 0.002 (32.77) NA 0.007 (102.02) 0.004(63.39)
ML (%) 107.79 (±7.42) 108.01 (±5.40) 107.08 (±7.51) 103.66 (±4.22) 109.88 (±5.93) 107.93 (±6.31) 106.5 (±4.91) 0.91 0.98 0.99 3.30 (3.07) 5.40 (5.05) 1.60 (1.49) 7.65 (7.10) 12.53 (11.73) 3.72 (3.46)
MLV (%/s) 47.53 (±27.71) 51.00 (±28.49) 46.09 (±30.65) 33.19 (±16.89) 32.65 (±16.70) 38.15 (±14.57) 32.22 (±12.86) 0.97 0.86 0.68 7.28 (15.11) 8.92 (27.09) 10.55 (29.98) 16.88 (35.24) 20.68 (62.81) 24.47 (69.53)

IntraWS, intra-rater within session; IntraBS, intra-rater between session; InterWS, inter-rater within session; rep, repetition; LV, Low Velocity; HV, High Velocity; HV-LV, Difference between HV and LV; VMAX, Maximum Velocity; ROM, Range of Motion; MVIC, Maximum Voluntary Isometric Contraction; rms-EMG, root mean squared electromyography; AOC, Angle of Catch; ML, Muscle Length; MLV, Muscle Lengthening Velocity. NA = Not Applicable. Performance-related parameters appear above the dashed line. Spasticity-related parameters appear below the dashed line.