Strong designs: often trustworthy effects
|
Multiple randomized controlled trials |
The “gold standard” of evidence |
Randomized controlled trials |
A strong design, but sometimes not feasible |
Interrupted time series with a control series |
Baseline trends often allow visible effects and controls for biases |
Intermediate designs: Sometimes trustworthy effects
|
Single interrupted time series |
Controls for trends, but has no comparison group |
Before and after with comparison group (single observations, sometimes called “difference in difference” design) |
Comparability of baseline trend often unknown |
Weak designs: rarely trustworthy effects (no controls for common biases, excluded from literature syntheses)
|
Uncontrolled before and after (pre–post) |
Simple observations before and after, no baseline trends |
Cross-sectional designs |
Simple correlation, no baseline, no measure of change |