Table 1.
Country | Target population | No. positive/ No. tested |
Estimated prevalence | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Target Population % |
General Population (95% CI) |
|||
U.K. (Wessex)41;121 |
SpEd population (ages 5–18 years), unknown etiology |
20/3,738 | SpEd: 0.5 | 1/5,530 (1/8,992–1/4,007) |
U.S.A. (Atlanta, Georgia)38;122 |
SpEd population (ages 7–10 years), regardless of etiology |
Caucasian: 4/1,572 African-American: 3/752 |
Caucasian SpEd: 0.3 African-American SpEd: 0.4 |
Caucasian: 1/3,717 (1/7,692–1/1,869) African-American: 1/2,545 (1/5,208–1/1,289) |
Southwest Netherlands 47 | Schools and institutes for MR, unknown etiology |
9/866 | Mild MR: 2.0 Moderate/ severe MR: 2.4 |
1/6,045 (1/9,981–1/3,851) |
Hellenic population of Greece and Cyprus 40 |
Referred clinical population of idiopathic MR |
8/611 | MR: 1.3 | 1/4,246 (1/16,440–1/1,333) |
Australia (Sydney) 36;37 |
Children with MR in SpEd |
10/472 | MR: 2.1 Mild MR: 0.6 Moderate/ severe MR: 5.4 |
1/4,350b |
France123 | Children with DSM-IIIR classification of MR |
10/403 | MR: 2.5 Mild MR: 1.4 Moderate/ severe MR: 3.6 |
- |
U.S.A. (Baltimore, Maryland) 46 |
Preschool children referred for language delay |
1/379 | Language delay: 0.3 | - |
China (mainland and Hong Kong)124 |
Persons with MR clinically referred or in SpEd |
31/902a | MR: 3.4 | - |
India (Delhi) 125 | Clinically referred children with MR, unknown etiology |
19/360 | MR: 5.3 | - |
Southern Häme, Finland 126 |
Adult males (>16 years) registered in the Southern Häme Care Organization with MR, unknown etiology |
6/344 | MR: 1.7 | 1/4,400c |
Finland 45 | Clinically referred persons with MR |
15/305 | MR: 4.9 | - |
U.S.A. (Colorado)127 |
Targeted “high risk” children (ages 2–18 years with MR, autism, LD, ADHD, family history) in SpEd population |
1/299 | SpEd: 0.3 | - |
Japan 128 | Institutionalized persons with MR |
8/298 | MR: 2.7 | - |
Indonesia (primarily Javanese)129 |
Schools for mild developmental delay, no cytogenetic abnormality |
5/262 | Mild MR: 1.9 | - |
Hellenic population of Greece and Cyprus 130 |
Referred clinical population of idiopathic MR |
4/257 | MR: 1.6 Moderate/ severe MR: 2.9 Profound MR: 3.6 |
- |
Brazil 131 |
Schools for the mentally disabled |
5/256 | MR: 2.0 Mild MR: 2.3 Severe MR: 1.6 |
- |
Japan 132 | Males with MR or psychomotor developmental delay, clinically referred |
2/256 | MR: 0.8 | - |
Singapore 133 | Children in schools for mild to severe MR, unknown etiology |
5/254 | MR: 2.0 | - |
Hong Kong 134 | Persons with mild MR, unknown etiology |
1/243 | Mild MR: 0.4 | - |
U.K. (Coventry)35;37;135 |
Children with MR in institutions or SpEd |
6/219 | MR: 2.7 Mild MR: 1.3 Moderate/ severe MR: 6.7 |
1/4,090d |
Chile 136 | Children in SpEd with MR of unknown etiology; excluded profound MR |
4/214 | MR: 1.9 | - |
Taiwan 137 | Persons with MR of unknown etiology enrolled in SpEd or private day-care centers |
4/206 | MR: 1.9 Mild MR: 3.8 Moderate/ severe MR: 0.8 |
- |
Poland (Warsaw)42 |
Males in institutions or SpEd with MR |
6/201 | MR: 3.0 | 1/2,857–1/5,882e |
Southwest Netherlands 138 | Clinically referred persons with MR and no known family history of fragile X |
10/197 | MR: 5.1 | - |
U.S.A. (New Mexico)139 |
Clinically referred persons with MR or behavior disorders, unknown etiology |
10/188 | MR: 3.7 LD: 1.1 Hyperactivity/AD: 0.5 |
- |
Spain 140 | Persons with MR in SpEd |
11/182 | MR: 6.0 | - |
U.K. (Wessex)39 |
SpEd population (ages 5–18 years), unknown etiology |
4/180 | SpEd: 2.2 | 1/8,918f |
Spain 43 | Children in SpEd or clinically referred with MR of unknown etiology; no known family history of MR |
5/180 | MR: 2.7 | 1/6,200–1/8,200g |
Turkey 141 | Clinically referred children with developmental disability |
5/166 | MR: 3.0 | - |
Guadeloupe, French West Indies 56 |
SpEd population, unknown etiology |
11/163 | SpEd: 6.7 | 1/2,359 (1/4,484–1/276) |
South Africa 142;143 | Institutionalized males (blacks) with idiopathic MR |
9/148 | MR: 6.1 Mild MR: 4.2 Severe MR: 7.8 |
- |
U.K.144 | Institutionalized males with learning disabilities, unknown etiology |
1/138 | LD: 0.7 | - |
U.K. (Oxfordshire)44 |
Children in schools for moderate to severe learning difficulties, unknown etiology |
4/103 | MR: 3.9 | 1/4,130h |
Thailand 145 | Children with developmental delay or MR, unknown etiology |
5/94 | MR: 5.3 | - |
India (New Delhi)146 |
Institutionalized persons with MR with unknown etiology that scored above 40% on a fragile X checklist 147 |
9/93 | MR: 9.7 | - |
Spain 53 | Persons in institutions or SpEd with idiopathic MR |
8/92 | MR: 8.7 | - |
Brazil 148 | Institutionalized persons with severe MR, unknown etiology |
0/83 | - | - |
Croatia 149 | Children clinically preselected for fragile X DNA analysis on the basis of MR of unknown etiology, a positive family history, and at least on physical and/or behavioral characteristic of the fragile X syndrome |
14/81 | 17.3 | - |
Mexico 150 | Children clinically referred with MR, unknown etiology |
2/53 | MR: 3.8 | - |
Abbreviations: Special education or special schools (SpEd), mental retardation (MR), learning disability (LD), attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), attention deficit (AD).
Zhong et al.124 did not distinguish between males and females in the published manuscript. The numbers presented in table 1 are derived from personal communication with Dr. Zhong.
Turner et al.37 provided on a point estimate.
Arvio et al.126 provided only a range on the basis of past cytogenetic and DNA-based diagnoses.
Morton et al.135 provided only a point estimate.
Mazurczak et al 42 provided only a range, not a point estimate.
Jacobs et al 39 provided only a point estimate.
Millan et al 43 provided a range, not a point estimate. Millan et al 43 also acknowledged that persons with mild MR might have been missed, so the range could be as high as 1/5,000–1/6,800.
Slaney et al 44 only provided a lower boundary, not a point estimate.