Table 7. Oligometastatic colorectal cancer.
1st Author, Year [Ref] | Strength of evidence- based on study design / endpoint | Prospective (P) / Retrospective (R) | Sample size | Definition- Oligo metastases | Therapy | Endpoint | Conclusion |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Engels, 2012 [104] | 2 /A | P | 24 | ≤ 5 mets | Resected primary tumor, and inoperable mets treated with helical tomotherapy | 1yr OS- 78% | Helical tomotherapy is an attractive for consolidation of inoperable OM disease after effective chemo |
Dellas, 2012 [110] | 2/ D | P | 9 | 1–3 mets or local recurrence plus max. 2 mets | CT + 3D-CRT to all met lesions | 3/9 pats survived 3.5–4.4 yrs; DLT not documented | 3D-CRT to mets feasible in addition to standard CT |
Van den Begin, 2014 [113] | 3ii/A | R | 47 | Resected primary + ≤5 mets, liver, lung, LNs | SBRT | 1yr OS- 53% | Nature + location of local recurrences demonstrated need for breathing management and dose >75Gy. |
Filippi, 2014 [114] | 3ii/A | R | 40 | Resected primary + 1–5 lung mets, max diameter <5cm | 3D conformational RT or image guided volumetric modulated arc therapy | 5yr OS- 39% | Suggests stereotactic ablative RT is safe + efficacious in CRC with lung oligometastases |
Kang, 2010 [117] | 3iii /A | R | 59 | 1–4 met lesions confined to 1 organ, largest <7cm, progressive after CT | Met lesions progressed after chemo, then treated SBRT | 5yr OS- 29% | Patients generally fare well after SBRT |
Salah, 2012 [112] | 3iii /A | R | 927 | Underwent lung metastasectomy | Lung metastasectomy | 5yr OS- 54.3%. Prognostic risk groups good-, intermediate-, and high-, had 5yr OS- 68%, 46%, 26% | More studies need to investigate if surgery offers advantage over CT in the poor-risk group |
Bae, 2012 [116] | 3iii/A | R | 41 | Met lesions confined to 1 organ | 3 fractions SBRT | 5yr OS- 38% | SBRT results comparable with Surgery |
Salah, 2013 [115] | 3iii /A | R | 148 | Repeat resection of pulmonary mets | Repeat resection of lung met | 5yr OS- 52% for 1 lung met resection, 58% 2 lung met resection. >2 lung mets + ≥3 cm risk factors for decreased survival | In selected patients, repeated pulmonary resection offers good survival outcome |
Comito, 2014 [111] | 3iii/A | P | 82 | 1–3 inoperable mets in 1 organ (Liver or lung) | SBRT | 3yr OS- 43% | SBRT safe + feasible treatment for mets not amenable to resection |
Abbreviations: Met(s) = metastasis(es); OS = overall survival; CT = chemotherapy; CRT = chemoradiation therapy; DLT = dose-limiting toxicity; SBRT = stereotactic body radiation therapy; LNs = lymph nodes; RT = radiation therapy; CRC = colorectal cancer