Skip to main content
. 2015 Jun 3;80(1):51–61. doi: 10.1111/bcp.12585

Table 1.

Risk of bias in included studies for outcomes of the systematic review

Study Random sequence generation Allocation concealment Blinding: Participants Blinding: Personnel Blinding: Outcomes Incomplete outcome assessment Selective reporting Other
Randomized controlled trials
Bladh et al. 26 Unclear Low High High Mortality: Unclear Mortality: High High
LOA: Unclear LOA: Low
Gillespie et al. 25 High Unclear Unclear Unclear Mortality: Unclear Mortality: Low Low Low
Re-admissions: Low Re-admissions: Low
ED revisits: Low ED revisits: Low
Lisby et al. 23 Unclear Unclear Unclear High Mortality: Unclear Mortality: Low Low
LOA: Unclear LOA: Low
Re-admissions: Unclear Re-admissions: Low
ED revisits: Unclear ED revisits: Low
Lisby et al. 22 Unclear Unclear Low High Mortality: Unclear Mortality: Low Low High
LOA: High LOA: Low
Re-admissions: Unclear Re-admissions: Low
ED revisits: Unclear ED revisits: Low
Scullin et al. 20 High Unclear High High Mortality: NA Mortality: Low Low NA
LOA: High LOA: Unclear
Re-admissions: High Re-admissions: Unclear
Controlled clinical trials
Makowsky et al. 24 High Unclear Low High LOA: High LOA: Low Low High
Re-admissions: Unclear Re-admissions: Low
ED revisits: Unclear ED revisits: Low
Spinewine et al. 21 High Unclear Low High Mortality: Low Mortality: High Unclear NA
Re-admissions: High Re-admissions: High
ED re-visits: High ED re-visits: High

CCT, controlled clinical trial;

HRQL, health-related quality of life;

LOA, length of admission;

NA, not applicable;

RCT, randomized controlled trial.