TABLE 1—
Examples of Well-Being in Research, Guidance, and Regulation
References (Year) | Use | Conception or Definition of Well-Being | Focus or Methods | Metrics or Indicators |
Research | ||||
Harter et al.38 | Relationship to business outcomes | “We see well-being as a broad category that encompasses a number of workplace factors. Within the overall category of well-being we discuss a hypothesized model that employee engagement (a combination of cognitive and emotional antecedent variables in the workplace) generates higher frequency of positive affect (job satisfaction, commitment, joy, fulfillment, interest, caring). Positive affect then relates to the efficient application of work, employee retention, creativity, and ultimately business outcomes.”(p2-3) | Meta-analysis of 36 companies involving 198 514 respondents | Employee engagement linked business outcomes |
Chida and Steptoe50 | Relationship to mortality | “Positive psychological well-being encompasses positive affect and related trait-like constructs or dispositions, such as optimism. . . . Positive affect can be defined as a state of pleasurable engagement with the environment eliciting feelings, such as happiness, joy, excitement, enthusiasm, and contentment.”(p741) | Systematic review of prospective cohort studies to determine link between well-being and mortality | 35 studies, hazard ratio = 0.82; 95% confidence interval = 0.76, 0.89 |
Huppert et al.121 | European Social Survey | “Well-being is a complex construct.”(p303) It is “people’s perceived quality of life, which we refer to as their ‘well-being.’”(p302) | Well-being module and questionnaire | 54 items, divided into 2 sections, corresponding to personal and interpersonal dimensions of well-being; each of these is further subdivided into feeling (being) and functioning (doing) |
Guidance or practice | ||||
Delwart et al.122 | Well-being in the workplace guide | Identify best practices related to well-being in the workplace | Key performance indicators | |
Schill and Choosewood123 | Guidance for Total Worker Health | “Total Worker HealthTM is a strategy integrating occupational safety and health protection with health promotion to prevent worker injury and illness and to advance health and well-being.”(pS8) “Promoting optimal well-being is a multifaceted endeavor that includes employee engagement and support for the development of healthier behaviors, such as improved nutrition, tobacco use/cessation, increased physical activity, and improved work/life balance.”(pS9) |
Guidance on how to integrate health protection and promotion | Various score cards |
Canadian Standards Association124 | Mental well-being guidelines | Psychological health and safety in the workplace | Developing an action plan for implementing the mental health and well-being strategy | Integrated approach |
Burton125 | WHO model for healthy workplace | “WHO’s definition of health is: ‘A state of complete physical, mental and social well-being, and not merely the absence of disease.’ In line with this, the definition of a healthy workplace . . . is as follows: A healthy workplace is one in which workers and managers collaborate to use a continual improvement process to protect and promote the health, safety, and well-being of all workers and the sustainability of the workplace.”(p90) | Framework for health protection and promotion | Continuous improvement method |
Regulation or policy | ||||
Pot et al.116 | WEBA (conditions of well-being at work policy) | Operational well-being in terms of organization of work and ergonomics | How to measure individual well-being | 3 value levels for 7 questions |
East Riding of Yorkshire Council126 | Psychological well-being at work policy | The mental health as well as the physical health, safety, and welfare of employees | Stress assessment (relating to work pressures) tool to develop action plan | Likert-like scoring |
Risk scoring | ||||
Ministry of Social Affairs and Health127 | Well-being at work policies | “Health, safety and well-being are important common values, which are put into practice in every workplace and for every employee. The activities of a workplace are guided by a common idea of good work and a good workplace. Good work means a fair treatment of employees, adoption of common values as well as mutual trust, genuine cooperation and equality in the workplace. A good workplace is productive and profitable.”(p4) | Policies to specify a ministerial strategy | Extend work 3 y |
“From the perspective of the work environment, a good workplace is a healthy, safe and pleasant place. Good management and leadership, meaningful and interesting tasks, and a successful reconciliation of work and private life are also characteristics of a good workplace.”(p4) | Reduce workplace accidents 25% | |||
Reduce psychic strain 20% | ||||
Reduce physical strain 20% |
Note. WEBA = conditions of well-being at work; WHO = World Health Organization.