Skip to main content
. 2015 May 15;29(7):902–912. doi: 10.1038/eye.2015.64

Table 3. Within-supplement group analysis of letter contrast sensitivity by intervention groups.

Intervention N Baseline, mean±SD 36 Months, mean±SD % Δ Sig. Baseline, mean±SD 12 Months, mean±SD % Δ Sig. 12 Months, mean±SD 24 Months, mean±SD Sig. 24 Months, mean±SD 36 Months, mean±SD % Δ Sig.
Letter CS 1.2cpd
 Group 1 12 1.87±0.25 1.89±0.16 1 0.817 1.87±0.25 1.96±0.23 5 0.222 1.96±0.23 1.76±0.22 −10 0.000 1.76±0.22 1.89±0.16 7 0.059
 Group 2 15 1.71±0.24 1.86±0.18 9 0.012 1.71±0.24 1.93±0.29 13 0.004 1.93±0.29 1.85±0.25 −4 0.207 1.85±0.25 1.86±0.18 1 0.861
 Group 3 13 1.75±0.31 1.82±0.20 4 0.432 1.75±0.31 1.89±0.27 8 0.069 1.89±0.27 1.86±0.24 −2 0.602 1.86±0.24 1.82±0.20 −2 0.494
                                   
Letter CS 2.4cpd
 Group 1 12 1.76±0.30 1.87±0.17 6 0.227 1.76±0.30 1.89±0.33 7 0.077 1.89±0.33 1.70±0.25 −10 0.011 1.70±0.25 1.87±0.17 10 0.065
 Group 2 15 1.68±0.31 1.81±0.21 8 0.087 1.68±0.31 1.86±0.31 11 0.000 1.86±0.31 1.78±0.26 −4 0.221 1.78±0.26 1.81±0.21 2 0.657
 Group 3 13 1.63±0.31 1.78±0.21 9 0.083 1.63±0.31 1.85±0.29 13 0.005 1.85±0.29 1.77±0.22 −4 0.225 1.77±0.22 1.78±0.21 1 0.947
                                   
Letter CS 6cpd
 Group 1 12 1.42±0.30 1.60±0.15 13 0.112 1.42±0.30 1.49±0.41 5 0.224 1.49±0.41 1.39±0.26 −7 0.200 1.39±0.26 1.60±0.15 15 0.037
 Group 2 15 1.37±0.24 1.52±0.25 11 0.040 1.37±0.24 1.44±0.30 5 0.079 1.44±0.30 1.39±0.34 −3 0.357 1.39±0.34 1.52±0.25 9 0.164
 Group 3 13 1.23±0.44 1.52±0.27 24 0.034 1.23±0.44 1.55±0.29 26 0.005 1.55±0.29 1.48±0.20 −5 0.357 1.48±0.20 1.52±0.27 3 0.547
                                   
Letter CS 9.6cpd
 Group 1 12 1.14±0.31 1.35±0.16 18 0.043 1.14±0.31 1.14±0.32 0 0.959 1.14±0.32 1.14±0.28 0 1.000 1.14±0.28 1.35±0.16 18 0.031
 Group 2 15 1.06±0.27 1.27±0.34 20 0.024 1.06±0.27 1.17±0.39 10 0.072 1.17±0.39 1.06±0.37 −9 0.115 1.06±0.37 1.27±0.34 20 0.025
 Group 3 13 0.94±0.48 1.30±0.22 38 0.020 0.94±0.48 1.17±0.44 24 0.031 1.17±0.44 1.23±0.27 5 0.503 1.23±0.27 1.30±0.22 6 0.201
                                   
Letter CS 15.15cpd
 Group 1 12 0.75±0.32 1.02±0.23 36 0.033 0.75±0.32 0.83±0.31 11 0.055 0.83±0.31 0.79±0.29 −5 0.509 0.79±0.29 1.02±0.23 29 0.011
 Group 2 15 0.70±0.37 0.91±0.38 30 0.083 0.70±0.37 0.78±0.44 11 0.278 0.78±0.44 0.60±0.47 −23 0.013 0.60±0.47 0.91±0.38 52 0.029
 Group 3 13 0.61±0.48 0.97±0.25 59 0.019 0.61±0.48 0.81±0.38 33 0.028 0.81±0.38 0.93±0.35 15 0.169 0.93±0.35 0.97±0.25 4 0.555

Abbreviations: CS, contrast sensitivity; cpd, cycles per degree; N, number of subjects; SD, standard deviation; Sig., level of significance set at P<0.05; %Δ, percentage change.

Letter contrast sensitivity was assessed using Thompson Test Chart PRO and recorded in the logarithm of contrast sensitivity (Log CS) units. Statistical significance was tested using paired t-test. The calculated percentage change from baseline to 36 months, calculated as the 36-month value minus baseline value divided by baseline value, multiplied by 100 (−, negative change; +, positive change); the calculated percentage change from baseline to 12 months, calculated as the 12-month value minus baseline value divided by baseline value, multiplied by 100 (−, negative change; +, positive change); the calculated percentage change from 12 to 24 months, calculated as the 24-month value minus the 12-month value divided by the 12-month value, multiplied by 100 (−, negative change; +, positive change); the calculated percentage change from 24 to 36 months, calculated as the 36-month value minus the 24-month value divided by the 24-month value, multiplied by 100 (−, negative change; +, positive change).

Group 1: 20 mg lutein and 0.86 mg zeaxanthin; Group 2: 10 mg meso-zeaxanthin, 10 mg lutein, and 2 mg zeaxanthin; Group 3: 17 mg meso-zeaxanthin, 3 mg lutein, and 2 mg zeaxanthin.