Table 4.
Identification and description of environmental and socioeconomic threats in the three Amazonian river basins sampled during the fieldwork: Upper Xingu River, Lower Tocantins River, and Mid Negro
| Threat | Description of threat | Upper Xingu River | Lower Tocantins River | Mid Negro River |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alteration and loss of fish habitats due to deforestation of riparian vegetation | Habitat conversion of riparian communities, from expansion of agriculture, cattle ranching and urbanization in floodplains | Intensively verified | Moderately verified | Not yet relevant |
| Effect of reduced river flow due to deforestation of headwater areas | Changes in upland areas (deforestation, expanding cattle ranching, urbanization) resulting indirectly in greater sediment loads and contaminants such as fertilizers and pesticide from run-off | Observed conversion of natural vegetation into huge areas of soybean crop fields | Moderately verified | Not yet relevant |
| Effect of environmental contaminants on the water quality | Direct contamination of rivers from increased dumping of organic and solid waste into rivers from expanding urban areas and from activities such as intensive agriculture and mining | Potential contamination of waters from agricultural fertilizers and pesticides | Urban sewage pollutants | Urban sewage pollutants |
| Effect of hydroelectric reservoirs on diversity and fish communities | Transformation of a lotic environment into a lake eradicating or reducing populations of rheophilic fish species, and providing favorable conditions for lentic species to proliferate | Moderate and specifically located effect from small hydroelectric plants | Tucuruí dam and plant operation: overall drastic effects on natural habitats and fish communities | Not relevant |
| Effect of infrastructure on diversity and fish communities | Changes in hydrological regimes through construction of infrastructure such as roads, ports and navigation channels | Moderate impact | Severe impact | Not relevant |
| Threats to turtles and freshwater mammals | Illegal hunting and commerce of wildlife | Moderate impact in the upper region but very severe in the lower portion (Belo Monte region) | Severe impact | Moderate impact |
| Effects of fishing conflicts | Detected growing number of conflicts among natural resource users | Moderate conflict between sport and subsistence fishing | Severe conflict among commercial fishing interests | Moderate conflict between ornamental and sport fishing |
| Decline of ornamental aquarium fishing | Capture of ornamental fish species for aquarium international commerce | Not relevant in the upper region but important in the lower area of Volta Grande do Xingu | Not relevant here | Negative socioeconomic effect due to decline in demand; fishermen are now starting to seek their livelihoods in other activities, such as agriculture |
| Effects of deficient implementation of fishing regulation | Lack of organizational and institutional capacity to deal with fishing in a participatory and integrated manner | Sport fishing observed here to be organized to take advantage of immediate income of fishing opportunity | Several fishing colonies exist but conflicts are still severe due to the lack of fishing regulation and implementation | Weakness of organization due to present decline in ornamental fishing |
| Effects of deficient dialogue between participant actors of fishing social organizations | Social organizations play a significant role in enabling fishery management to ensure sustainability | Strong organization among owners of sport fishing accommodation but low concern for sustainability | Conflicts among subsistence, commercial and sport fishing | Drastic decline in dialogue due to decline in demand for ornamental fishing |
| Effects of overfishing | Overexploitation of fishery resources is observed when fish stocks are suppressed to a level where fishing in a given region is no longer sustainable, that is, there is a need to increase fishing effort and stocks are not replenished naturally | Competition between sport fishing and artisanal subsistence fishing. Smaller fish sizes. | Observed strong pressure on fishing stocks to meet demand | Sport fishing in increasing demand and ornamental fishing in decline |
| Effects of global climate change on aquatic environments | The published literature indicates that it appears highly possible that the predicted climate change over the next decades may well cause additional damage to Amazon aquatic ecosystems | Regionally subject to drying change due to intense and extended deforestation | Regionally subject to change due to drastic environmental change—Tucuruí dam | Forest still well preserved |