Table 2.
ID | Source – Country – Study design | Starting year + duration in months | Criteria used for assessment of Audiological Risk | Healthcare Setting | Tests | Number of tests (before discharge; after d.; total) | Extent of Hearing Loss for screening phase | Operator performing the test | Testing environmental conditions |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Bevilacqua M, 2010 [33] – Brasil - Hospital-based series | not exactly known, starting from 2004 to 2007 + 36 m | JCIH 2007 | 1 Hospital | OAEa | 1; 1; 2 | 40 dB HL; unilateral | Audiologist | Non-sound-treated room (average noise < 45 dB) |
2 | Calevo M, 2007 [34] – Italy – multicentric Hospital-based series | 2002, February + 35 m | JCIH 1994 | 13 Hospitals | Bothb | 1; 3; 4 | 50 dB SPLb,c; unilateral | N.R. | Sound-proof and faradized room |
3 | Cebulla M, 2012 [35] – Germany - Hospital-based series | 2006, March + 60 m | N.R. | 1 Well baby nursery - University maternity clinic | ABRa | 1; 1; 2 | 35 dB nHLd (aABR); unilateral | Trained physician assistants, nurses | Quiet room (stage 1); acoustically and electrically shielded room(stage 2) |
4 | De Capua, 2007 [36] – Italy – Multicentric hospital-based series | 1998, April + 100 m | JCIH, 2000 | 3 hospitals | Bothe | 1; 2; 3 | 30 dB nHLd; unilateral | Technician | Silent room |
5 | Guastini L, 2010 [37] – Italy - Hospital-based series | 2006, January + 36 m | Ad hoc | 1 University Hospital | Bothb | 1; 3; 4 | 40 dB HL; unilateral | ENT specialists experienced in neonatal screening techniques | Sound-proof and faradised room |
6 | Habib H, 2005 [38] – Saudi Arabia - Hospital-based series | 1996, September + 89 m | JCIH 1994 | 1 Hospital | OAEa | 2; 0; 2 | 26 dB HL; unilateral | Technician | N.R. |
7 | Kennedy C, 2005 [39] - UK - Prospective cohortf | 1993, October + 36 m | Ad hoc | 4 Hospitals | Botha | 2; 0; 2 | 40 dB HL; bilateral | Trained nurse | N.R. |
8 | Korres S, 2008 [40] – Greece - Hospital-based series | N.R. + N.R. | N.R. | 1 Hospital | OAE | 3; 1; 4 | 40 dB HL; unilateral | Audiologist | Quite room |
9 | Lin H, 2007 [41] – Taiwan - Retrospective cohort | a) 1998, November + 60 m; | N.R. | 1 Hospital | a) OAEa
b) Botha c) ABRa |
a) 2–3; 0; 2–3 b) 2; 0; 2 c) 2; 0; 2 |
N.R.; unilateral | N.R. | N.R. |
b) 2004, February + 12 m; | |||||||||
c) 2005, March + 14 m | |||||||||
10 | Rohlfs AK, 2010 [42] – Germany – multicentric hospital based series | 2002 August + 48 m | Ad hoc | 14 birth clinics and children hospitals | Both | 2; 1; 3 | 35 dB (aABR); unilateral | Trained nurses and physicians | N.R. |
11 | Tatli MM, 2007 [43] – Turkey - Prospective cohort | 2002 + 18 m | Ad Hoc | 1 University Hospital | OAEa | 1; 1; 2 | N.R.; unilateral | N.R. | Quite room |
12 | Tsuchiya H, 2006 [44] – Japan - Prospective cohort | 1999, July + 64 m | N.R. | 1 Hospital | ABRa | 1; 1; 2 | 35 dB HL (aABR); unilateral | Technician | N.R. |
aNo differences for neonates with audiological risk were specified
bWith both automatic and diagnostic ABR
cEquivalent to about 40db HL in voice frequency
ddB nHL = Decibel Normal Hearing
eDiagnostic instead of automatic ABR
fData not reported in Kennedy have been gathered from Wessex [45]