Table 3.
Benefits from CTC effects on sustained abstinence from delinquency, alcohol use, and cigarette smoking through Grade 12
| CTC effects at Grade 12 |
Sensitivity analysis: Developer involvement adjustment - Effects reduced by 50% |
||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Criminal Justice | Victimization | Earnings | Health Care | Property Loss | Total | 95% Confidence Interval [low; high] | Total | 95% Confidence Interval [low; high] | |
| Delinquency | |||||||||
| Participants | $960 | ($17) | $943 | [$919; $967] | $486 | [$467; $506] | |||
| Taxpayers | $598 | $353 | $133 | $1085 | [$1070; $1100] | $562 | [$550; $574] | ||
| Othersa | $1729 | ($100) | $1629 | [$1605; $1653] | $836 | [$813; $859] | |||
| DWCb | $299 | $454 | $67 | $820 | [$803; $837] | $421 | [$410; $433] | ||
| Total | $897 | $1729 | $1767 | $83 | $4477 | [$4413; $4540] | $2305 | [$2254; $2357] | |
| Alcohol use | |||||||||
| Participants | $176 | $4 | $181 | [$168; $193] | $87 | [$81; $94] | |||
| Taxpayers | $1 | $65 | $13 | $80 | [$75; $84] | $40 | [$37; $42] | ||
| Othersa | $4 | $10 | $1 | $15 | [$15; $16] | $13 | [$12; $13] | ||
| DWCb | $1 | $3 | $7 | $11 | [$10; $11] | $6 | [$6; $6] | ||
| Total | $2 | $6 | $245 | $34 | $1 | $287 | [$269; $304] | $145 | [$136; $154] |
| Cigarette smoking | |||||||||
| Participants | $4 | $3 | $7 | [$7; $8] | $3 | [$3; $3] | |||
| Taxpayers | $1 | $9 | $10 | [$10; $11] | $4 | [$4; $5] | |||
| Othersa | $9 | $9 | [$8; $10] | $4 | [$3; $4] | ||||
| DWCb | $14 | $5 | $19 | [$17; $20] | $7 | [$6; $7] | |||
| Total | $20 | $25 | $45 | [$43; $48] | $17 | [$16; $19] | |||
a
This category includes benefits to crime victims and private health insurance companies.
b
This category includes benefits related to the deadweight cost (DWC) of taxation, second-hand smoking benefits, and avoided household production losses when early mortality is reduced.