Table 2.
Treatment Efficacy Measure | Effect size (Hedges’ g) | Treatment Response Measure | Relative Risk of Treatment Resposne | Symptom /Diagnostic Remission Measure | Relative Risk of Symptom/Diagnostic Remission | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
CBT Trials | ||||||
Barrett et al. 2004 | CYBOCS | 2.82 | 25% CYBOCS Reduction | 19.00 | ADIS-P | 43.00 |
POTS, 2004a | CYBOCS | 1.06 | 25% CYBOCS Reduction | 2.50 | CYBOCS ≤10 | 15.00 |
Bolton & Perrin, 2007 | CYBOCS | 1.02 | 25% CYBOCS Reduction | 13.00 | CYBOCS ≤14 | 2.50 |
Freeman et al. 2008 | CYBOCS | 0.49 | CGI-I | 1.25 | CYBOCS ≤12 | 2.50 |
Williams et al. 2010 | CYBOCS | 1.31 | 25% CYBOCS Reduction | 3.18 | CYBOCS ≤14 | 2.73 |
Bolton et al. 2011 | CYBOCS | 1.45 | 25% CYBOCS Reduction | 3.87 | ADIS-C/P | 7.33 |
Piacentini et al. 2011 | CYBOCS | 0.38 | CGI-I | 2.10 | CYBOCS ≤10 | 2.54 |
Storch et al. 2011 | CYBOCS | 1.15 | CGI-I | 6.09 | CYBOCS ≤10 | 4.22 |
Lewin et al. 2014 | CYBOCS | 1.62 | CGI-I | 9.06 | CYBOCS ≤12 | 17.50 |
Freeman et al. 2014 | CYBOCS | 1.18 | CGI-I | 1.76 | CYBOCS ≤14 | 1.94 |
| ||||||
SRI Trials | ||||||
Flament et al. 1985b | NIMH-GOCS | 0.78 | NA | --- | NA | --- |
Leonard et al. 1989b | NIMH-GOCS | 0.78 | NA | --- | NA | --- |
March et al. 1990c | CYBOCS | 0.51 | NA | --- | NA | --- |
DeVeaugh-Geiss et al. 1992 | CYBOCS | 0.73 | CGI-I | 3.56 | NA | --- |
Riddle et al. 1992 | CYBOCS | 0.78 | NA | --- | NA | --- |
March et al. 1998 | CYBOCS | 0.62 | CGI-I | 1.61 | NA | --- |
Geller et al. 2001 | CYBOCS | 0.44 | CGI-I | 2.93 | 40% CYBOCS Reduction | 1.97 |
Riddle et al. 2001 | CYBOCS | 0.31 | CGI-I | 1.88 | NA | --- |
Liebowietz et al. 2002 | CYBOCS | 0.24 | CGI-I | 1.80 | CYBOCS ≤14 | 1.44 |
Geller et al. 2004 | CYBOCS | 0.40 | CGI-I | 1.38 | NA | --- |
POTS, 2004a | CYBOCS | 0.44 | 25% CYBOCS Reduction | 2.13 | CYBOCS ≤10 | 11.00 |
placebo group used in both,
used a cross-over trial design
NOTE: CY-BOCS = Children’s Yale-Brown Obsessive-Compulsive Scale, NIMH-GOCS = National Institute of Mental Health Global Obsessive Compulsive Disorder Scale, NA = Not Available/Applicable, CGI-I = Clinical Global Impression of Improvement, ADIS-C/P = Anxiety Disorder Interview Schedule-Child and Parent report