APPENDIX.
Responses to Knowledge and Demand Questions Among Parents in 2000 Versus 2013 for Medicaid and Commercial Insurance, Weighted
Medicaid Insurance | Commercial Insurance | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2000, N (%) | 2013, N (%) | P | 2000, N (%) | 2013, N (%) | P | ||
Total knowledge | |||||||
1. How often are antibiotics needed for sore throat? | Sometimes or almost never | 211 (83) | 126 (80) | NS | 680 (90) | 173 (94) | NS |
2. How often are antibiotics needed for colds or flu? | Almost never | 109 (45) | 69 (44) | NS | 560 (74) | 142 (78) | NS |
3. How often are antibiotics needed for ear infection? | Almost always or sometimes | 244 (96) | 139 (87) | <.01 | 740 (96) | 176 (94) | NS |
4. How often are antibiotics needed for runny nose or green nasal discharge? | Almost never | 56 (22) | 50 (32) | .02 | 176 (23) | 91 (49) | <.01 |
5. How often are antibiotics needed for deep cough or bronchitis? | Almost never | 13 (5) | 19 (12) | <.01 | 66 (9) | 26 (14) | .02 |
6. How often are antibiotics needed for middle ear fluid? | Sometimes or almost never | 74 (29) | 66 (43) | <.01 | 337 (44) | 104 (56) | <.01 |
7. How often are antibiotics needed for strep throat? | Almost always | 232 (90) | 110 (71) | <.01 | 684 (89) | 162 (87) | NS |
8. Are most colds caused by bacteria or viruses? | Virus | 165 (61) | 98 (61) | NS | 610 (81) | 163 (86) | NS |
9. Are antibiotics helpful in treating bacteria, viruses, or both? | Bacterial | 137 (51) | 60 (38) | <.01 | 552 (73) | 137 (72) | NS |
10. If my child does not receive an antibiotic for cold, will he or she be sick for a longer time? | Disagree or strongly disagree | 131 (48) | 82 (51) | NS | 527 (69) | 138 (73) | NS |
High antibiotic expectation | |||||||
1. I will take my child to another doctor. | Strongly agree or agree | 28 (10) | 40 (25) | <.01 | 59 (8) | 19 (10) | NS |
2. If I expect an antibiotic, I am less satisfied if I don’t receive one. | Strongly agree or agree | 26 (10) | 39 (24) | <.01 | 109 (14) | 29 (15) | NS |
3. I would rather give my child an antibiotic than wait and see. | Strongly agree or agree | 25 (9) | 30 (19) | <.01 | 62 (8) | 11 (6) | NS |