Skip to main content
. 2015 Jun 29;112(29):8987–8992. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1414495112

Table S3.

Interrater reliability for the 32 features

Feature % agreement Kappa
Aerophone use 96.7 0.905
Instrument use 96.7 0.870
Voice use 93.3 0.850
Discrete pitches 93.3 0.714
Word use 93.3 0.441
Chest voice 93.3 NA
Metrical hierarchy 90.0 0.603
Dissonant homophony 90.0 0.571
Pentatonic scale 90.0 0.500
≤7 scale degrees 90.0 −0.043
Nonequidistant scale 90.0 NA
Sex segregation 86.7 0.767
Group performance 86.7 0.426
Isochronous beat 86.7 0.259
Syllabic singing 83.3 0.578
Two- or three-beat subdivisions 83.3 NA
Loud volume 80.0 0.585
Percussion use 80.0 0.532
Vocal embellishment 80.0 0.508
Short phrases 80.0 0.260
Two-beat subdivisions 76.7 0.452
Membranophone use 76.7 0.386
Motivic patterns 73.3 0.172
Idiophone use 70.0 0.363
High register 66.7 0.282
Small intervals 66.7 0.189
Descending/arched contour 66.7 NA
Phrase repetition 63.3 0.127
Vocable use 63.3 0.086
Few durational values 60.0 −0.017
Male performers 56.7 0.649
Dance accompaniment NA NA
Average 80.8 0.445

The data are based on codings of 30 randomly-selected recordings by P.E.S. and E.S. (SI Materials).