Table 7.
References | Focus of research | Research design | Sample characteristics | Key findings |
---|---|---|---|---|
(32) Casado and Sacco (2012) | Identify correlates of caregiver burden | Phone survey | 146 first-generation KA CGs | • Family support rather than friends alleviated caregiver burden. • Care management efficacy positively impacted caregiver burden. |
(33) Chun, Knight, and Youn (2007) | Compare caregiving distress | Face-to-face interview | 63 Koreans, 53 first-generation KA, 54 CA CGs | • CRs’ behavior, memory problem, and depression affected KA CGs’ burden, depression, and anxiety. • CGs’ immigrant status exacerbated reactions to CRs’ disability due to conflicts between Korean and American values. • CGs with higher education had lower levels of anxiety. |
(34) Han, Choi, Kim, Lee, and Kim (2008) | Explore caregiving experiences | Focus group | 24 first-generation KA CGs | • CGs faced challenges of settling in a new country but holding on to traditional but changing value of filial responsibility. • CGs had no systematic support: Need education and culturally tailored support. • Due to different levels of acculturation within family members, conflicts arose in terms of beliefs related to caregiving. |
(35) Kim and Theis (2000) | Describe the caregiving role in the KA family | Face-to-face interview | 30 first-generation KA CGs | • Being CGs as “privilege,” but meant negative as no other choice but being CGs. • Caregiving while working outside home was challenging. • CGs concerned about future finances due to low-wage jobs with limited education. |
(36) Kim and Knight (2008) | Investigate the effects of CG on physical health | Face-to-face interview | 87 KA CGs and 87 non-CGs | • Significant associations were found between low quality of instrumental social support and CGs’ poor health (e.g., hypertension, physiological stress). |
(37) Kim (2009) | Understand dementia and CGs’ postcaregiving experience | Face-to-face interview | 8 first-generation KA CGs | • CGs appraised AD as a disease, accepted themselves as CGs, and caregiving as family affair. • CGs examined filial responsibility through maintaining harmony but changing its expectations across generations. • Due to immigrant status, CGs wondered if their CRs might have been in better condition if they remained in Korea. |
(38) Knight, Robinson, Flynn Longmire, Chun, Nakao, and Kim (2002) | Assess the relationship between cultural values and stress/coping | Questionnaire and face-to-face interview | 53 first-generation KA CGs | • Lower education, younger age, CRs’ higher depression, and embarrassment were significant predictors of higher anxiety. • KA showed higher familism and higher levels of burden and distress, indicating worse mental and physical health. |
(39) Kong, Deatrick, and Evans (2010) | Describe CGs’ experiences re American nursing home placement | Face-to-face interview | 10 first-generation KA CGs | • The Korean way of thinking, “family and filial piety” as a fundamental cultural belief of caregiving, was salient. • Placing a loved one to a nursing home made CGs feel inadequate. • Nursing home services were better than expected. |
(40) Lee and Farran (2004) | Compare CGs’ depressive symptom | Mail survey | 100 Korean, 59 first-generation KA, and 78 CA CGs | • All three groups showed high scores on depressive mode (Korean = 85%, KA = 71%, Caucasian = 63%). • KA CGs were difficult to recruit due to the conflict of filial duty and work outside home—Process of acculturation. |
(41) Lee and Bronstein (2010) | Examine the role of culture in the meaning of caregiving | Mail survey | 72 KA CGs | • Social support was the most important factor in determining the meaning of caregiving. • Cultural factors were insignificant in CGs’ meaning of caregiving. |
(42) Yong and McCallion (2003) | Examine the meaning of caregiving experiences | Phone interview | 2 first-generation KA daughters-in-law CGs | • CGs constructed meanings of their lives based on hierarchical relationships within their family. When CGs’ behavior did not fit within the relationship, it made CGs feel guilty and stressed (hwabyung). • Family support was the best influence on caregiving experience. |
Note. KA = Korean American; CG = caregiver; CA = Caucasian American; CR = care recipient; AD = Alzheimer's disease.