Skip to main content
. 2015 Jul 31;10(7):e0134546. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0134546

Table 5. Effects of La3+ and AR on the contents of mineral elements and La in soybean.

AR (pH) La3+ (mM) K (%) Ca (%) Mg (%) Fe (μg g-1) Mn (μg g-1) Cu (μg g-1) Zn (μg g-1) La (μg g-1)
Roots
3.0 0.00 2.39±0.06 a bc b (105.78) 0.58±0.01a (110.90) 1.34±0.03b (106.50) 334.08±6.33h 146.64) 69.65±1.52b (111.18) 9.00±0.15e (126.36) 37.03±0.77i (75.29) 0.18±0.00h (135.06)
0.08 1.96±0.03d (86.60) 0.53±0.01c (100.33) 0.99±0.02de (78.35) 370.30±9.19f (162.54) 36.04±0.85f (57.53) 10.7±0.17c (150.18) 55.44±0.91f (112.73) 57.46±1.05f (42390.96)
0.40 1.55±0.03h (68.42) 0.34±0.01f (65.13) 0.95±0.02ef (75.27) 516.19±9.65c (226.58) 26.43±0.58h (42.19) 11.01±0.18bc (154.48) 42.55±0.8h (86.52) 209.45±4.14c (154532.39)
1.20 1.22±0.02i (53.80) 0.27±0.01i (52.63) 0.8±0.01g (63.34) 655.27±12.19a (287.63) 21.24±0.39ij (33.91) 7.41±0.12hi (103.94) 31.79±0.73j (64.64) 222.41±6.68a (164094.42)
3.5 0.00 2.59±0.05a (114.28) 0.56±0.01ab (107.89) 1.37±0.03b (108.97) 249.55±4.21ij (109.54) 101.81±2.78a (162.52) 9.22±0.18e (129.36) 41.23±0.75h (83.83) 0.18±0.00h (133.978)
0.08 2.41±0.06b (106.56) 0.55±0.01abc (105.67) 1.01±0.02d (79.86) 365.47±9.31fg (160.42) 38.52±0.64f (61.5) 11.86±0.19a (166.39) 57.69±0.96ef (117.31) 56.63±1.30f (41780.06)
0.40 1.77±0.03e (78.5) 0.39±0.01e (74.92) 0.82±0.02g (65.23) 450.00±9.62d (197.53) 23.84±0.54hi (38.06) 11.33±0.20b (158.98) 42.07±0.86h (85.54) 175.36±4.58d (129378.92)
1.20 1.32±0.02i (58.37) 0.29±0.01gh (56.54) 0.57±0.01h (44.99) 570.75±11.57b (250.53) 18.09±0.36k (28.88) 10.83±0.17c (151.99) 32.11±0.56j (65.29) 211.25±6.20bc (155860.45)
4.5 0.00 2.63±0.15a (116.43) 0.55±0.01abc (105.84) 1.57±0.03a (124.58) 251.97±5.23ij (110.60) 67.39±1.12b (107.58) 8.39±0.15f (117.81) 43.52±0.76h (88.5) 0.11±0.00h (81.58)
0.08 2.42±0.04b (107.14) 0.46±0.01d (89.10) 0.91±0.02f (72.46) 341.32±6.98gh (149.82) 52.61±1.04e (83.978) 11.07±0.18bc (155.36) 49.16±1.24g (99.96) 42.26±0.84g (31182.13)
0.40 1.73±0.03ef (76.51) 0.44±0.01d (83.96) 0.49±0.02i (38.70) 459.66±10.93d (201.77) 20.07±0.48jk (32.039) 10.11±0.18d (141.95) 62.16±1.18d (126.40) 183.2±3.68d (135169.27)
1.20 1.59±0.04fh (70.56) 0.30±0.01g (58.14) 0.34±0.01j (27.35) 505.54±8.97c (221.91) 18.03±0.48k (28.78) 9.74±0.15d (136.66) 74.12±1.32b (150.72) 214.13±4.82ab (157985.34)
7.0 0.00 2.26±0.05c (100.00) 0.52±0.01c (100.00) 1.26±0.03c (100.00) 227.82±4.88j (100.00) 62.64±1.42c (100.00) 7.13±0.15i (100.00) 49.18±0.90g (100.00) 0.146±0.00h (100.00)
0.08 2.36±0.05bc (104.61) 0.55±0.01ab (106.17) 0.9±0.02f (71.47) 259.21±6.17i (113.78) 58.02±1.2d (92.63) 7.92±0.13g (111.13) 60.04±1.00de (122.09) 40.82±0.81g (30116.73)
0.40 1.56±0.03h (68.88) 0.54±0.01bc (102.88) 0.51±0.02i (40.48) 413.77±9.32e (181.63) 29.57±0.69g (47.20) 10.11±0.19d (141.84) 68.07±1.22c (138.42) 144.97±2.83e (106961.26)
1.20 1.33±0.03i (58.76) 0.35±0.01f (67.19) 0.29±0.01k (22.69) 464.49±10.49d (203.89) 31.18±0.75g (49.77) 7.64±0.13gh (107.20) 84.17±1.45a (171.15) 203.08±4.78c (149831.05)
F 86.455 112.614 394.345 201.875 477.839 84.197 230.695 698.207
p * * * * * * * *
Leaves
3.0 0.00 3.17±0.05b (124.06) 2.98±0.07ab (98.64) 1.27±0.03a (131.46) 273.70±4.67c (141.08) 35.31±0.80d (121.23) 7.64±0.12bc (141.98) 55.14±1.58ab (119.43) 0.28±0.0j (142.43)
0.08 2.02±0.03f (78.99) 2.78±0.06def (92.06) 1.16±0.02b (120.10) 289.18±5.44b (149.06) 24.96±0.94hi (85.71) 8.08±0.14a (150.21) 49.19±0.85def (106.55) 1.29±0.02fg (646.57)
0.40 1.87±0.03f (73.04) 2.88±0.07ad (95.18) 0.97±0.02d (100.24) 280.91±4.66bc (144.80) 22.00±0.74j (75.52) 6.92±0.11e (128.53) 45.36±1.04h (98.25) 1.19±0.03g (597.77)
1.20 1.37±0.02g (53.60) 2.31±0.04h (76.26) 1.03±0.02c (106.89) 308.5±5.05a (159.01) 21.39±0.82j (73.44) 4.96±0.01h (92.11) 55.98±1.20ab (121.25) 1.45±0.03e (726.36)
3.5 0.00 3.40±0.07a (132.99) 2.99±0.06ab (98.79) 0.98±0.02cd (101.73) 268.76±5.14c (138.53) 46.34±0.97b (159.10) 7.96±0.15ab (147.87) 57.05±1.08a (123.58) 0.30±0.01j (151.82)
0.08 2.75±0.06c (107.50) 2.81±0.06cde (93.05) 0.9±0.02e (93.13) 256.80±4.34d (132.37) 27.21±0.93fgh (93.42) 7.41±0.24cd (137.79) 53.89±1.21bc (116.74) 0.87±0.02i (438.73)
0.40 1.46±0.03g (57.01) 2.65±0.05fg (87.45) 0.82±0.01f (85.20) 290.61±5.05b (149.79) 27.89±0.84fg (95.75) 7.02±0.11de (130.45) 46.2±0.98fgh (100.07) 2.02±0.05d (1014.39)
1.20 0.90±0.01h (35.32) 2.67±0.06efg (88.30) 0.88±0.01e (91.04) 305.15±5.18a (157.26) 29.21±0.58f (100.30) 5.753±0.09g (106.79) 53.69±1.13bc (116.30) 4.01±0.08a (2014.81)
4.5 0.00 2.74±0.04c (107.40) 2.96±0.06abc (97.94) 0.96±0.02d (99.28) 227.82±4.50fg (117.43) 50.81±1.07a (174.45) 6.73±0.22ef (125.10) 51.51±1.03cde (111.57) 0.24±0.00j (119.52)
0.08 2.31±0.04e (90.24) 2.84±0.05bd (93.83) 0.89±0.02e (92.50) 238.50±4.59ef (122.93) 32.63±0.73e (112.05) 7.80±0.19abc (144.99) 45.56±1.10 (98.69) 1.08±0.02h (539.75)
0.40 0.91±0.02h (35.59) 2.83±0.05bd (93.76) 0.85±0.01ef (87.71) 256.80±4.28d (132.37) 33.74±0.83de (115.83) 8.24±0.14a (153.16) 48.62±1.05efg (105.31) 1.38±0.03ef (690.85)
1.20 0.47±0.01i (18.23) 2.85±0.06bd (94.18) 0.98±0.02cd (101.71) 249.55±3.96de (128.63) 38.34±0.62c (131.62) 7.9±0.13ab (146.91) 49.12±0.85defg (106.4) 2.61±0.05c (1309.54)
7.0 0.00 2.55±0.19d (100.00) 3.02±0.06a (100.00) 0.97±0.02d (100.00) 194.01±3.68i (100.00) 29.12±1.39f (100.00) 5.38±0.13gh (100.00) 46.17±1.02gh (100.00) 0.20±0.00j (100.00)
0.08 2.64±0.05cd (103.48) 2.96±0.06abc (98.01) 0.87±0.02ef (89.37) 210.91±3.90h (108.71) 25.83±0.53gh (88.68) 6.41±0.17f (119.07) 51.71±0.97cd (112.01) 0.90±0.02i (450.83)
0.40 0.82±0.01h (31.99) 2.80±0.05def (92.51) 0.87±0.02ef (90.47) 218.16±3.60gh (112.45) 22.74±0.84ij (78.07) 6.59±0.22ef (122.58) 47.21±0.98fgh (102.26) 1.47±0.04e (736.22)
1.20 0.41±0.01i (16.17) 2.55±0.04g (84.33) 0.86±0.02ef (88.98) 225.40±4.89g (116.18) 22.69±0.89ij (77.91) 6.94±0.14e (129.01) 39.78±0.65i (86.17) 2.96±0.05b (1484.68)
F 260.631 11.263 38.990 56.762 98.209 40.238 19.556 909.757
p * * * * * * * *

a Values are means ± standard deviation errors, n = 5.

b Significantly differences at p < 0.05 were showed with different letter in each column.

* Significance at 0.05 levels.