Skip to main content
. 2015 Aug 1;15:738. doi: 10.1186/s12889-015-1954-4

Table 1.

A summary of the scientific evidence for variables with sufficient data to draw a conclusion on the association between work environment factors and future depressive symptoms

Work-related factor Participants Studies Scientific evidence
Relationship between occupational environment and less depressive symptoms
Control 158 251 19 graphic file with name 12889_2015_1954_Figa_HTML.gif
Relationship between occupational environment and more depressive symptoms
Demands - psychological job demands 53 985 10 graphic file with name 12889_2015_1954_Figb_HTML.gif
Job strain 197 682 14 graphic file with name 12889_2015_1954_Figa_HTML.gif
Passive job (low decision latitude, low job demands) 11 419 2 graphic file with name 12889_2015_1954_Figb_HTML.gif
High pressure job 34 554 5 graphic file with name 12889_2015_1954_Figb_HTML.gif
Effort reward imbalance 27 136 3 graphic file with name 12889_2015_1954_Figb_HTML.gif
Low support at the work place 82 772 17 graphic file with name 12889_2015_1954_Figb_HTML.gif
- Low supervisor support 50 935 8 graphic file with name 12889_2015_1954_Figb_HTML.gif
- Low co-worker support 27 170 6 graphic file with name 12889_2015_1954_Figb_HTML.gif
Poor social climate at the work place 9 242 2 graphic file with name 12889_2015_1954_Figb_HTML.gif
Poor social capital at the work place 59 340 2 graphic file with name 12889_2015_1954_Figb_HTML.gif
Low work place justice 33 589 5 graphic file with name 12889_2015_1954_Figb_HTML.gif
- Procedural injustice 33 589 5 graphic file with name 12889_2015_1954_Figb_HTML.gif
- Relational injustice 30 761 3 graphic file with name 12889_2015_1954_Figb_HTML.gif
Work place conflicts 13 732 3 graphic file with name 12889_2015_1954_Figb_HTML.gif
- Conflicts with superiors 9 692 2 graphic file with name 12889_2015_1954_Figb_HTML.gif
- Conflicts with co-workers 9 692 2 graphic file with name 12889_2015_1954_Figb_HTML.gif
Bullying 15 173 3 graphic file with name 12889_2015_1954_Figa_HTML.gif
Low job development 15 173 4 graphic file with name 12889_2015_1954_Figb_HTML.gif
Job insecurity 24 833 7 graphic file with name 12889_2015_1954_Figb_HTML.gif
Long working week 13 107 6 graphic file with name 12889_2015_1954_Figb_HTML.gif
The scientific evidence is in-sufficient (Inline graphic) to determine if there is a relationship between the following occupational factors and depressive symptoms/
Demands (several types of demands), Demands (emotional), Distributive justice, Threats, Violence, Irregular, Irregular work hours, Physically demanding work, Pesticides, Solvents, Heavy metals

Inline graphic - There is scientific evidence for an association between exposure and outcome. The result is based on studies of high or moderate quality. The quality of evidence has been upgraded due to consistency of the data (control and job strain) or large magnitude of effect (bullying)

Inline graphic - There is scientific evidence for an association between exposure and outcome. The result is based on studies of high or moderate quality

Inline graphic - It is not possible to determine if there is any association between exposure and outcome. The motivation is that one or several conditions apply: 1) no study fulfilled the inclusion criteria, 2) none of the studies fulfilling the inclusion criteria were relevant to the hypothesis tested in the present review, 3) all relevant studies were of low quality or 4) studies were of high or moderate quality - but one or several limitations applied, e.g. inconsistency of data between studies