Table 8. Physiological indicators changed during nebulization.
Groups | Before nebulization | 5 min after nebulization | 10 min after nebulization | 15 min after nebulization | 20 min after nebulization | P |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
SpO2 | ||||||
ON group | 92.33±3.23 | 97.47±1.48 | 97.77±1.28 | 97.63±1.30 | 97.30±1.95 | <0.001 |
UN group | 93.57±2.25 | 92.70±2.77** | 91.33±3.14** | 90.87±3.47** | 90.70±3.16** | <0.001 |
UNWO group | 92.42±2.91 | 95.71±2.85†† | 95.65±2.64**†† | 95.48±3.21**†† | 95.42±2.91**†† | <0.001 |
HR | ||||||
ON group | 90.90±11.86 | 88.40±11.75 | 87.83±11.97 | 88.43±12.26 | 87.60±11.94 | <0.001 |
UN group | 90.67±12.44 | 92.23±12.79 | 93.47±12.57 | 93.07±12.55 | 93.30±11.80 | 0.017 |
UNWO group | 89.35±12.78 | 87.52±11.89 | 88.42±12.02 | 88.42±12.53 | 88.87±11.45 | 0.293 |
RR | ||||||
ON group | 23.13±3.59 | 16.53±2.62 | 15.80±2.59 | 16.47±2.76 | 17.07±3.35 | <0.001 |
UN group | 22.33±3.64 | 16.73±4.08 | 18.33±4.67** | 18.93±4.89* | 19.47±4.93* | <0.001 |
UNWO group | 24.52±10.28 | 16.84±3.53 | 16.45±3.53† | 17.16±3.26 | 17.87±3.26 | <0.001 |
Dyspnea | ||||||
ON group | 2.23±1.16 | 1.75±0.94 | 1.55±0.86 | 1.37±0.83 | 1.30±0.81 | <0.001 |
UN group | 2.17±1.16 | 2.12±1.15 | 2.40±1.09** | 2.53±1.07** | 2.62±1.24** | 0.009 |
UNWO group | 2.39±1.54 | 2.11±1.35 | 2.02±1.21 | 1.97±1.10* | 1.89±1.09† | 0.049 |
Chest tightness | ||||||
ON group | 1.70±2.02 | 1.29±1.66 | 1.21±1.43 | 1.09±1.32 | 0.92±1.23 | 0.009 |
UN group | 1.47±2.19 | 1.33±2.01 | 1.27±1.93 | 1.30±1.88 | 1.33±1.86 | 0.283 |
UNWO group | 1.55±1.84 | 1.40±1.58 | 1.23±1.54 | 1.29±1.56 | 1.15±1.42 | 0.064 |
*, P<0.05; **, P<0.01 vs. ON group; †, P<0.05; ††, P<0.01 vs. UN group. SpO2, peripheral oxygen saturation; HR, heart rate; RR, respiratory rate; ON, oxygen-driven nebulization; UN, ultrasonic nebulization; UNWO, ultrasonic nebulization with warming and oxygen.