Skip to main content
. 2015 Aug 5;10(8):e0134589. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0134589

Table 1. Summary of comparative studies meeting inclusion criteria for analysis.

Study Country Study period Paints (n) Stone size (mm) Stone location Additional medications I/C # (mg/day) F (weeks) Study quality*
Pedro[15] USA 2008 34 35 3.96 3.67 LU NR Alfuzosin 10 mg Control 4 5
Cha[12] Korean 2012 36 30 34 5.81 5.73 5.59 LU Trospium chloride (50 mg, tablet) every 8 hours Alfuzosin 10 mg Tamsulosin 0.4mg Control 4 5
Ibrahim[11] Iraq 2013 40 40 32 5.94 5.58 5.65 UU LU Diclofenac potassium orally 50 mg and/or diclofenac sodium as an intramuscular injection of 75 mg on demand Alfuzosin 10 mg Tamsulosin 0.4 mg Control 4 4
Gurbuz[16] Turkey 2011 34 33 6.83 7.13 LU Drink at least 3 L of fluids daily; Diclofenac injection (75 mg) intramuscularly on demand for pain relief Alfuzosin 10 mg Control 2 4
Chau[18] China 2011 33 34 6.7 6.9 UU LU Dologesic (paracetamol+dextropropoxyphene) 4 tablets daily on a demand basis for 2 weeks Alfuzosin10 mg Control 6 3
Agrawal[13] India 2008 34 34 34 6.70 6.17 6.35 LU Drink at least 3 L of fluids daily; Diclofenac injection (75 mg) intramuscularly on demand for pain relief Alfuzosin10 mg Tamsulosin 0.4 mg Control 4 5
Ahmed[14] KSA 2010 30 30 28 5.47 4.97 5.39 LU Diclofenac sodium (50 mg, tablet) every 12 hours for 1 week; Diclofenac sodium injection (75 mg, amp) as needed Alfuzosin 10 mg Tamsulosin 0.4 mg Control 4 3
Sameer[17] India 2014 35 35 6.26 6.37 LU Diclofenac sodium (50 mg, tablet) every 12 hours for 1 week; Diclofenac sodium injection (75 mg, amp) as needed Alfuzosin 10 mg Control 4 5
Morua[19] Mexico 2009 15 15 5.80 6.43 LU Buscopan 10 mg/8h plus ketorolac 10 mg/8h Alfuzosin 10 mg Control 4 2

NR = not record; UU = upper ureter; LU = lower ureter; F = follow-up

# Control group receiving placebo or dologesic

* Using Jadad scale (score from 0 to 5)