Table 3.
Summary of participants, study design, and outcomes.
| First author | Year | Participants | Study design | Comparison condition(s) | Outcomes at post-AAI | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| N | Age (years) | Gender (% male) | Type of trauma | |||||
| Woolleya | 2004 | 21 | 11–17 | 52 | Abuse | Non-randomized control | Residential care without farm visits | ↓ Anxiety (pre-session*, pre-AAI−, post-comparison−) ↓ Depression (pre-session*b, pre-AAI−, post-comparison−) − Global functioning |
| Hamama | 2011 | 9 | 14–16 | 0 | Abuse | Pre-post | None | ↓ PTSD symptoms (pre-AAI*) ↓ Depression (pre-AAI†) − Coping, subjective well-being |
| McCullougha | 2011 | 11 | 10–18 | 55 | Abuse | Pre-post | None | ↓ PTSD symptoms (pre-AAI*) ↑ Human-animal bond (pre-AAI*) |
| Dietz | 2012 | 153 | 7–17 | 7 | Abuse | Non-randomized control | Group therapy without animal | ↓ PTSD symptoms (pre-AAI***, post-comparison−) ↓ Depression (pre-AAI***, post-comparison***) ↓ Anxiety, dissociation, anger (pre-AAI***, post-comparison**) ↓ Sexual concerns (pre-AAI**, post-comparison*) |
| Nevins | 2013 | 1 | 52 | 100 | War | Pre-post | None | ↓ PTSD symptoms, depression, dissatisfaction ↑ Happiness, resilience, satisfaction, sleep, social support |
| Murrowa | 2013 | 9 | 4–12 | 33 | Abuse | Pre-post | None | ↑ Approach behaviors toward the dog − Social-emotional competencies |
| Balluerka | 2014 | 46 | 12–17 | 70 | Abuse | Non-randomized control | Residential care without farm visits | ↑ Attachment security (pre-AAI*, post-comparison−) − Trauma, family concern, parental interference, self-sufficiency |
| Kemp | 2013 | 30 | 8–17 | 20 | Abuse | AB | Individual counseling without animal | ↓ Depression, maladaptive behavior (pre-AAI ***, post-comparison**) for children ↓ PTSD symptoms, anxiety, depression, dissociation, sexual concerns (pre-AAI ***, post-comparison**) for adolescents |
| Lass-Hennemann | 2014 | 80 | – | 0 | Video | Randomized control | Stuffed dog, person, or alone | ↓ Anxiety, negative affect (alone**, stuffed dog*, person−) − Blood pressure, cortisol level, heart rate, positive affect |
| Newtona | 2014 | 6 | – | 83 | War | – | None | ↓ Depression, fear of public spaces, medication use, nightmares ↑ Outreach |
AAI, Animal-Assisted Intervention; PTSD, Posttraumatic Stress Disorder; −, not reported; Pre-post, simple pre-test and post-test only; AB, waitlist + treatment; ↑ greater, ↓ less, − minimal/no change at post-AAI compared to pre-session (comparison of before to after individual AAI sessions), pre-AAI (comparison of before to after the AAI program in its entirety), and/or post-comparison condition (comparison of after the AAI program to after the control condition);
p < 0.10;
p < 0.05;
p < 0.01;
p < 0.001.
Unpublished thesis.
Significant at one of three time points. The largest p-value was used if multiple tests evaluated the same outcome.