Table 3.
T0 (mean ± SD) | T1 (mean ± SD) | T2 (mean ± SD) |
P-values
|
|||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
(T1 vs T0) | (T2 vs T1) | (T2 vs T0) | ||||
Uf(mm) | ||||||
Group 1 | ||||||
Leg | 0.230±0.15 | 0.195±0.16 | 0.645±0.72 | 0.305 (ns) | 0.003** | 0.007** |
Forearm | 0.815±0.42 | 0.742±0.42 | 1.173±0.70 | 0.083 (ns) | 0.004** | 0.021* |
Hand | 0.941±0.43 | 0.816±0.40 | 1.173±0.71 | 0.509 (ns) | 0.561 (ns) | 0.004** |
Zygomatic | 1.798±0.67 | 2.009±0.75 | 1.889±0.75 | 0.500 (ns) | 0.837 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) |
Forehead | 0.614±0.36 | 0.706±0.86 | 1.006±0.86 | 0.451 (ns) | 0.169 (ns) | 0.031* |
Group 2 | ||||||
Leg | 0.223±0.12 | 0.188±0.11 | 0.559±0.64 | 0.934 (ns) | 0.352 (ns) | 0.492 (ns) |
Forearm | 0.772±0.22 | 0.711±0.23 | 1.272±0.66 | 1.000 (ns) | 0.171 (ns) | 0.223 (ns) |
Hand | 0.867±0.16 | 0.826±0.54 | 1.196±0.72 | 1.000 (ns) | 0.322 (ns) | 0.395 (ns) |
Zygomatic | 1.594±0.77 | 1.735±0.91 | 1.711±0.89 | 1.000 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) |
Forehead | 1.005±0.68 | 0.872±0.70 | 1.067±0.83 | 1.000 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) |
Uf–Ua (mm) | ||||||
Group 1 | ||||||
Leg | 0.032±0.02 | 0.036±0.03 | 0.774±0.59 | 1.000 (ns) | 0.001*** | 0.001*** |
Forearm | 0.105±0.06 | 0.093±0.06 | 0.805±0.68 | 0.364 (ns) | 0.001*** | 0.001*** |
Hand | 0.318±0.22 | 0.247±0.13 | 0.826±0.77 | 1.000 (ns) | 0.014* | 0.012* |
Zygomatic | 1.024±0.65 | 1.323±0.83 | 1.235±0.97 | 0.380 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) | 0.819 (ns) |
Forehead | 0.183±0.11 | 0.263±0.19 | 0.758±0.56 | 0.852 (ns) | 0.018* | 0.030* |
Group 2 | ||||||
Leg | 0.032±0.02 | 0.022±0.01 | 0.469±0.46 | 0.403 (ns) | 0.522 (ns) | 0.549 (ns) |
Forearm | 0.121±0.06 | 0.087±0.03 | 0.814±0.80 | 0.255 (ns) | 0.226 (ns) | 0.267 (ns) |
Hand | 0.163±0.13 | 0.368±0.30 | 0.899±0.89 | 0.975 (ns) | 0.546 (ns) | 0.252 (ns) |
Zygomatic | 0.709±0.53 | 1.261±0.88 | 1.231±0.97 | 0.484 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) | 0.490 (ns) |
Forehead | 0.651±0.54 | 0.525±0.55 | 0.845±0.85 | 1.000 (ns) | 0.690 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) |
Ua/Uf | ||||||
Group 1 | ||||||
Leg | 0.838±0.06 | 0.826±0.09 | 0.604±0.35 | 1.000 (ns) | 0.002** | 0.001** |
Forearm | 0.820±0.14 | 0.809±0.13 | 0.644±0.32 | 1.000 (ns) | 0.020* | 0.008** |
Hand | 0.782±0.21 | 0.776±0.18 | 0.647±0.29 | 1.000 (ns) | 0.086 (ns) | 0.017* |
Zygomatic | 0.577±0.27 | 0.505±0.27 | 0.595±0.32 | 0.624 (ns) | 0.134 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) |
Forehead | 0.746±0.14 | 0.727±0.19 | 0.590±0.29 | 1.000 (ns) | 0.044* | 0.015* |
Group 2 | ||||||
Leg | 0.824±0.07 | 0.838±0.08 | 0.655±0.30 | 1.000 (ns) | 0.406 (ns) | 0.365 (ns) |
Forearm | 0.790±0.08 | 0.795±0.06 | 0.607±0.31 | 1.000 (ns) | 0.316 (ns) | 0.280 (ns) |
Hand | 0.765±0.15 | 0.723±0.20 | 0.617±0.33 | 0.756 (ns) | 0.907 (ns) | 0.666 (ns) |
Zygomatic | 0.626±0.26 | 0.543±0.23 | 0.591±0.30 | 1.000 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) |
Forehead | 0.612±0.22 | 0.680±0.26 | 0.610±0.32 | 1.000 (ns) | 0.847 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) |
Ur/Ue | ||||||
Group 1 | ||||||
Leg | 1.201±0.29 | 1.300±0.31 | 0.925±0.63 | 0.539 (ns) | 0.011* | 0.051 (ns) |
Forearm | 0.860±0.28 | 0.823±0.22 | 0.622±0.38 | 1.000 (ns) | 0.026* | 0.006** |
Hand | 0.744±0.37 | 0.768±0.33 | 0.590±0.35 | 1.000 (ns) | 0.068 (ns) | 0.084 (ns) |
Zygomatic | 0.403±0.24 | 0.328±0.25 | 0.385±0.26 | 0.476 (ns) | 0.402 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) |
Forehead | 0.738±0.22 | 0.712±0.27 | 0.619±0.44 | 1.000 (ns) | 0.715 (ns) | 0.410 (ns) |
Group 2 | ||||||
Leg | 1.166±0.24 | 1.230±0.43 | 0.926±0.53 | 1.000 (ns) | 0.406 (ns) | 0.365 (ns) |
Forearm | 0.765±0.17 | 0.792±0.10 | 0.529±0.34 | 1.000 (ns) | 0.211 (ns) | 0.288 (ns) |
Hand | 0.721±0.31 | 0.713±0.38 | 0.615±0.41 | 1.000 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) |
Zygomatic | 0.453±0.31 | 0.326±0.21 | 0.443±0.29 | 0.670 (ns) | 0.446 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) |
Forehead | 0.571±0.29 | 0.654±0.33 | 0.606±0.42 | 1.000 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) |
Uv/Ue | ||||||
Group 1 | ||||||
Leg | 0.963±0.26 | 1.081±0.32 | 0.797±0.57 | 0.277 (ns) | 0.040* | 0.280 (ns) |
Forearm | 0.624±0.19 | 0.631±0.16 | 0.463±0.27 | 1.000 (ns) | 0.012* | 0.015* |
Hand | 0.576±0.33 | 0.615±0.26 | 0.461±0.26 | 1.000 (ns) | 0.065 (ns) | 0.307 (ns) |
Zygomatic | 0.260±0.18 | 0.215±0.21 | 0.231±0.16 | 0.995 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) |
Forehead | 0.689±0.24 | 0.661±0.26 | 0.589±0.56 | 1.000 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) | 0.966 (ns) |
Group 2 | ||||||
Leg | 0.979±0.24 | 1.051±0.39 | 0.864±0.54 | 1.000 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) |
Forearm | 0.630±0.20 | 0.686±0.15 | 0.442±0.25 | 0.640 (ns) | 0.080 (ns) | 0.166 (ns) |
Hand | 0.544±0.12 | 0.588±0.23 | 0.490±0.28 | 1.000 (ns) | 0.777 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) |
Zygomatic | 0.368±0.24 | 0.309±0.23 | 0.334±0.29 | 1.000 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) |
Forehead | 0.561±0.24 | 0.606±0.32 | 0.535±0.42 | 1.000 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) | 1.000 (ns) |
Notes:
P<0.05,
P<0.001.
Abbreviations: ns, not significant; SD, standard deviation; T0, day 0; T1, day 15; T2, day 30; Uf, extensibility; Uf–Ua, the ability of the skin to return to its original state; Ua/Uf, total elasticity (including pulse stretching and recovery); Ur/Ue, elastic function; Uv/Ue, viscoelasticity; vs, versus.