Skip to main content
. 2015 Aug 7;10(8):e0127815. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0127815

Table 1. Characteristics of the studies included in the meta-analysis.

Study (First Author) Country Year of publication Jadad Score Diagnostic Criteria Type Depression Comorbidity Control Sample (M/F) No. of subjects in treatment group Dropout due to side effects in treatment group No. of subjects in control group Dropout due to side effects in control group Antidepressants Course Follow-up
Heefner JD USA 1978 4 clinical diagnosis and investigations no report few placebo 44(no report) 22 3 22 1 Desipramine 150mg qn 2M 2M
Myren J Norway 1982 3 clinical diagnosis and investigations no report no report placebo 61(28/33) 30 0 31 0 Trimipramine 50mg qn 4W 4W
Drossman USA and Canada 2003 7 Rome I no report partly placebo 172(0/172) 115 / 57 / Desipramine 50 mg qdfor 1 week, 100 mg qd for 1 week, and then 150 mg qd from week 3 to week 12 12W 12W
Vahedi H Iran 2008 6 Rome II IBS-D no report placebo 54(30/24) 27 1 27 1 Amitriptyline 10 mg qn 2M 2M
Abdul-Baki H Lebanon 2009 7 Rome II IBS-C, IBS-D, IBS-M no placebo 107(62/45) 59 14 48 6 Imipramine 25mg qd. Doubling the dose was allowed once at week 2. 12W 12W
Masand PS USA 2009 4 Rome II no report no placebo 72(9/63) 36 3 36 2 Paroxetine controlled-release;started at 12.5mg po qd,increased biweekly in 12.5 mg/d; maximum dose 50mg po qd; mean dose 30mg po qd 12 W 12 W
Creed F England 2003 3 Rome I IBS-C, IBS-D, other partly routine care 172(35/137) 86 29 86 / Paroxetine 20 mg po qd 3 M 3M, 1Y
Kuiken SD Holland 2003 7 Rome I IBS-C, IBS-D, IBS-A no placebo 40(18/22) 19 2 21 4 Fluoxetine 20mg po qn 6 W 6 W
Tack J Belgium 2006 4 RomeII IBS-C, IBS-D, IBS-A no placebo 23(5/18) 11 1 12 1 Citalopram 20 mg during the first three weeks and 40 mg during the second three weeks 6 W 3 W, 6W
Ladabaum U USA 2010 7 Rome II IBS-C, IBS-D, IBS-A no placebo 54(10/44) 27 7 27 2 Citalopram 20 mg qd for 4 weeks, then 40 mg qd for 4 weeks 8 W 4 W, 8 W
Vahedi H Iran 2005 6 Rome II pain and IBS-C no severe placebo 44(17/27) 22 0 22 0 Fluoxetine 20mg po qd 12W,16W 12W, 16W
Talley NJ Australia 2008 6 Rome II IBS-C, IBS-D no placebo 34(13/21) 18 / 16 / Imipramine beginning at a dose of 25 mg qn; then increased 2 weeks later to 50 mg qn 12W 12W
Talley NJ Australia 2008 6 Rome II IBS-C, IBS-D no placebo 33(13/20) 17 / 16 / Citalopram beginning at 20 mg qd andincreased to 40 mg qd 2 weeks later 12W 12W