Table 1. Initial studies examining resting calcium in dystrophic muscle based on fluorescent dyes.
Study | mdx [Ca2+] nM | WT [Ca2+] nM | Dye | Muscle | Isolation technique | Dye loading | Calibration parameters | Temperature |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Turner (23) | 92±9.8 | 40±2.8 | Fura-2 tetracarboxylate | FDB | Mechanical dissection | Microinjection | Identical between mdx and WT | 37 °C |
Turner (23) | 282±13 | 201±6 | Fura-2/AM | FDB | Mechanical dissection | Passive loading | Identical between mdx and WT | 37 °C |
Gailly (24) | 123±12 | 125±9 | Fura-2/AM | Soleus | Collagenase digestion | Passive loading | Different between mdx and WT | 20 °C |
Gailly (24) | 45.2±3 | 44.9±4 | Fura-2/AM | FDB | Collagenase digestion | Passive loading | Different between mdx and WT | 20 °C |
Head (12) | 45.7+4.1 | 46.2±3.9 | Fura-2 tetracarboxylate | FDB | Collagenase digestion | Microinjection | No significant difference | 22 °C |
Collet (25) | 48±7 | 56±5 | Indo-1 | FDB and interosseous | Collagenase digestion | Microinjection | No significant difference | 20–22 °C |
Abbreviations: FDB, flexor digitorum brevis; WT, wild-type; [Ca2+], calcium concentration. The initial study in the mdx mouse by Turner found a difference in basal intracellular calcium in myofibers between the mdx and the C57 mouse. They found this difference regardless of whether they used active or passive loading. Interestingly, this study was the only study to utilize mechanical dissection and the only study to find a statistically significant difference. Overall, technical challenges associated with photometric measurement of calcium, in conjunction with challenges associated with fiber isolation and selection bias, may explain the negative data that were also observed