Skip to main content
. 2014 Dec 22;50(4):1043–1068. doi: 10.1111/1475-6773.12274

Table 5.

Summary of Results and Robustness Testing

BC Screening CRC Screening CC Screening ACS|Admission
Marg Eff p-value Marg Eff p-value Marg Eff p-value Marg Eff p-value
Baseline marginal effects—δP (outcome)
 Acq1A −0.0525 .0000 0.0245 .0000 0.0257 .0000 −0.0017 .8730
 Acq1B 0.0043 .8310 0.0174 .0760 0.0023 .8420 −0.0036 .8460
 Acq2 0.0348 .0110 −0.0091 .1370 0.0213 .0060 0.0401 .0090
 Outcome Mixed Favorable Favorable Negative
 Passed Bonferroni Test? Yes Yes Yes Yes
Testing alternate control groups
 Compare only to those not vertically integrated (MS1&2, PC1&2) Consistent results Consistent results; loss of precision Consistent results; large loss of precision Consistent results; loss of precision
 Compare only to those not vertically integrated and multispecialty (MS1&2) Consistent results Consistent results; large loss of precision Consistent results; loss of precision Consistent results; loss of precision
 Compare only to those always vertically integrated (IDS1-5) Consistent results Consistent results Consistent results Consistent results
 Compare only to those always vertically integrated and involved in acquisitions (IDS1&2) Consistent results Consistent results Consistent results; loss of precision Consistent results
 Compare only to IDS1 (always vertically integrated and involved in acquisition) Consistent results; loss of precision Consistent results Consistent results Consistent results
 Compare only to IDS2 (always vertically integrated and involved in acquisitions) Consistent results Consistent results Opposite results Consistent results
Testing placebo treatment effects
 IDS1 as acq; IDS2&3 as control Incr prob Not stat sig by Bonferroni test Not stat sig by Bonferroni test Not stat sig by Bonferroni test
 PC1 as acq; MS1 as control Not stat sig by Bonferroni test Not stat sig by Bonferroni test Not stat sig by Bonferroni test Not stat sig by Bonferroni test
 MS1 as acq; IDS5 as control Incr prob Not stat sig by Bonferroni test Not stat sig by Bonferroni test Not stat sig by Bonferroni test
Future Readmit|Admission ED Appropriate 1 + IP Admits 1 + ED Visits
Marg Eff p-value Marg Eff p-value Marg Eff p-value Marg Eff p-value
Baseline marginal effects—DP (outcome)
 Acq1A −0.0163 .0870 0.0031 .7220 −0.0065 .0110 −0.0102 .0040
 Acq1B 0.0032 .8550 0.0212 .0630 −0.0054 .2500 0.0064 .3000
 Acq2 0.0085 .4870 0.0227 .0040 −0.0022 .4690 0.0118 .0070
 Outcome None Favorable Favorable Mixed
 Passed Bonferroni Test? No Yes No Yes
Testing alternate control groups
 Compare only to those not vertically integrated (MS1&2, PC1&2) N/A Consistent results; increased precision N/A Consistent results; loss of precision
 Compare only to those not vertically integrated and multispecialty (MS1&2) N/A Consistent results; increased precision N/A Consistent results for Acq1A; increased precision
 Compare only to those always vertically integrated (IDS1-5) N/A Consistent results; loss of precision N/A Consistent results
 Compare only to those always vertically integrated and involved in acquisitions (IDS1&2) N/A Consistent results; loss of precision N/A Consistent results
 Compare only to IDS1 (always vertically integrated and involved in acquisition) N/A Consistent results N/A Consistent results
 Compare only to IDS2 (always vertically integrated and involved in acquisitions) N/A Consistent results N/A Consistent results
Testing placebo treatment effects
 IDS1 as acq; IDS2&3 as control N/A Not stat sig by Bonferroni test N/A Decr prob
 PC1 as acq; MS1 as control N/A Not stat sig by Bonferroni test N/A Not stat sig by Bonferroni test
 MS1 as acq; IDS5 as control N/A Not stat sig by Bonferroni test N/A Decr prob